Greener Journal of Agricultural Sciences
ISSN: 2276-7770; ICV: 6.15
Vol. 4 (2), pp. 034-038, March 2014
Copyright ©2017, the copyright of this article is retained by the author(s)
Research Article (DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15580/GJAS.2014.2.041513577)
Comparative Assessment of Growth Performance and Economics of Production of Clarias gariepinus Fingerlings in Ponds and Tanks
*Reginald Inodu Keremah and James Esquire
Department of Fisheries and Livestock Production Technology, Niger Delta University, Wilberforce Island, Bayelsa State.
Article No.: 041513577
An experiment was conducted to compare the growth and economics of producing Clarias gariepinus in ponds (6.4x5.4x1.5m3) and tanks (2.5x1.1x1.2m3) for 56days. Fingerlings of Clarias gariepinus (mean weight, 1.80g and body length, 4.40cm) were stocked at 250 and 50 fish separately into each pond and tank in duplicates. Fish were fed a commercial feed containing 45% crude protein at 5% body weight. It was divided into two halves and fed at 1000 and 1600hours daily. At final harvest, the total yield of fish was significantly greater (P<0.05) in pond, 3.0kg than those in tank, 1.81kg. There was no significant difference (P>0.05) in mean weight gain (13.75+0.95g, 13.44+0.95g), condition factor (0.92+0.03, 0.91+0.03) and feed conversion ratio (0.56+0.01, 0.51+0.01) between fingerlings stocked in pond and tank. Fish in pond had higher percentage weight gain and specific growth rate while survival rate ranged 74.11+0.54-88.80+0.54% in the culture media. Net profits obtained were
Reginald Inodu Keremah
E-mail: regreggie55 @yahoo.com
Comparative Study, Growth, Economics, Pond, Tank, Clarias gariepinus
Fish farming in Nigeria has progressed steadily over the years. The size of operation varies between 0.02-0.20ha for small-scale earthen ponds, 25-40m2 for homestead concrete tanks and 3ha and above for commercial farms (FDF, 1990). Production estimate was put at 1ton/hectare/year for small-scale ponds. These productions were achieved by using low input semi-intensive culture level in homestead ponds and commercial fish farms in Nigeria (FDF, 1996). Ponds are the most widely used structures for aquaculture production. In Africa, especially in Nigeria, the species mostly cultured are Clarias gariepinus, Heterobranchus sp. and their hybrids (Adewolu et al., 2008). The reasons for their culture are based on their fast growth rate, disease resistance, high stocking density, aerial respiration, high feed conversion efficiency among others (Adewolu et al., 2008). Adebayo and Adesoji (2008) also reported that Clarias gariepinus cultured in earthen pond had a high yield.
The culture of fish in concrete tanks is now a common practice in Nigeria. Homestead fish farmers operate in concrete tanks whose sizes and shapes vary from location to location depending on individual taste, availability of space and financial resources (Omitoyin, 2007). Intensive tank culture can produce very high yields on small parcels of land. Species like Tilapia that grow well in high densities in confinement of tanks are preferred. However, Dambo and Rana (1992) suggested a low stocking rate of 2, 5 and 10 fish/m3 for the hybrid catfish (Heteroclarias) in 2x2x1m3 concrete tanks to improve survival rate and production efficiency.
The importance of Clarias gariepinus as a choice fish and as an inexpensive protein source in rural communities is shown by the geographical distribution, economic potential, availability and as fish food in Nigeria (Ayinla, 1985). This fish is ideal for culture because of its tolerance to low dissolved oxygen, rapid growth rate and acceptability of a variety of food items (Bard et al., 1976), resistance to handling stress and is well appreciated in a wide number of African countries (Hogendoorn, 1979).
Recent investments in Agriculture in Nigeria have been targeted on Catfish farming (Abdullah, 2007). Currently about 90% of farmed fish in Nigeria is Catfish which is now a major attraction to private sector investors (Kamthorn and Miller, 2006). Atanda (2007) reported that live catfish attracted premium price in Nigeria with a high return on investment ranging between 40-60% in some successful enterprises. Investment in catfish is still growing especially with the renewed awareness being created by the government of Nigeria through the Presidential Initiative on Fisheries and Aquaculture (Miller and Atanda, 2004).
The type of culture medium used and their management have a significant influence on fish profitability (Ross and Waten, 1995). According to Hankins et al. (1995), fish culture medium and their accessories add up to a large portion of farm capital. The need therefore arises to choose the best production system with a good operating strategy to optimize fish farm profitability. Therefore the aim of this study was to evaluate the growth performance, survival and the economics of producing Clarias gariepinus in earthen pond and concrete tank culture environments.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A total of 650 Clarias gariepinus fingerlings (mean weight, 1.80g and total length, 4.40cm) were obtained from a Fish Farm in Delta State, Nigeria. They were acclimatized and maintained with a commercial feed (Coppens) containing 45% protein for 7days prior to use for the experiment. Thereafter, the fish were randomly stocked at 250 each into earthen ponds with dimension, 6.4m x 5.4m x 1.5m and 50fish into each concrete tank, 2.5m x 1.1m x 1.2m in duplicates. The stocked fish were fed with the Coppens feed at 5% body weight. Daily rations were divided into two halves and fed at 1000 and 1600hours. At bi-weekly intervals, the fish in each culture facility were weighed and the amount of feed adjusted accordingly.
Water quality parameters were determined on a weekly basis during the experimental period. Water temperature record was taken daily with a laboratory mercury thermometer (0-100oC). Dissolved oxygen (DO), pH, ammonia and total hardness were determined using Hach’s Aquaculture Test Kit (Model FF-2). Length and weight measurements of the fingerlings were made at the start of experiment and weekly intervals using a metal metre rule and triple beam balance (Model MB-2610). Daily mortalities of fish in ponds and tanks were also recorded. This experiment was conducted for 8weeks from March to May, 2011 at the Fish Farm site of Department of Fisheries and Livestock Production Technology, Niger Delta University in Bayelsa State, Nigeria. Uneaten feed and waste products were siphoned off from the tanks with a rubber tube and water was allowed to flow through them throughout the study period.
Biological performance of test fish were evaluated as follows: mean weight gain (MWG) = W2-W1 (Okoye et al., 2001) where W1 and W2 are initial and final body weights of fish (g). Percentage weight gain (PWG), % = Wt-Wox100/Wo (Adewolu et al., 2008) where Wt = final weight (g) at end of experiment, Wo = fish weight (g) at start of experiment. Specific growth rate (SGR), %day-1 = lnw2-lnw1x100/t2-t1 (Brown, 1957) where w2 = final weight of fish, w1 = initial weight of fish (g), t2 and t 1 = mean of end of growth period and at time 0 in days and ln = natural logarithm. Condition factor (K) = 100w/l3 (Bagenal and Tesch, 1978) where w and l are the observed total weight (g) and total length (cm) of a fish. Feed conversion ratio (FCR) = Feed intake (g)/weight gain (g), Utne (1979) and Survival of fish (S) = Ni x 100/No (Alatise and Otubusin, 2006) where No and Ni are number of fish at start and end (alive) of experiment. For economic evaluation, the profit index and incidence of cost were according to Mazid et al. (1997) with profit index = number of fish produced/cost of feed (
N), incidence of cost (R) = cost of feed ( N)/mass of fish produced (kg), net profit = sales–expenditure and Benefit : Cost ratio = total sales/total expenditure.
Data obtained from this study were subjected to analysis of variance (Wahua, 1999). Duncan’s multiple range test (Duncan, 1955) was used to compare differences among treatment means. Treatment were considered significant at P<0.05.
Table 1 shows the summary of the results obtained for growth responses of Clarias gariepinus fingerlings raised in pond and concrete tank environments. There was a general increase in weight and length in all fish during the experimental period. The mean weight of fish in pond was 13.75+0.95g and tank, 13.44+0.95g but similar in SGR for both pond (1.03+0.0%day-1) and tank (1.00+0.0%day-1). Condition factor of 0.92+0.03 and 0.91+0.03 were observed for pond and tank. However, fish survival varied between 74.11+0.54-88.80+0.54% for tank and pond. Feed conversion ratio was fairly the same for fish in both pond (0.56+0.01) and tank (0.51+0.01) culture facilities. Total fish yield and percentage weight gain were higher in pond than values obtained for fish in the tank situation.
The incidence of cost was 0.67+0.0 for pond and 1.67+0.01 for tank. The profit index varied between 0.02+0.0 and 0.45+0.01 for tank and pond while the Benefit: Cost ratio was 1.19 for pond and 1.38 for tank.
The values of the physico-chemical parameters monitored during the rearing period are shown in Table 2. Mean water temperature was 25.05+0.07oC for pond and 26.20+0.07oC for tank. Dissolved oxygen varied between 5.25+0.14mg/l for tank and 6.00+0.14mg/l for pond. Mean pH in tank was 7.50+0.17 while pond had 8.20+0.17. Ammonia values ranged 0.30+0.04mg/l-0.40+0.04mg/l for tank and pond culture environments. The mean total hardness in pond was higher (60.0+0.92mg/l) than in the tank (55.0+0.92mg/l).
The growth, feed utilization and cost benefits depended on the culture facility for the fish raised. At the end of study period, the mean weight gain in pond was slightly better than fish in the tank. However, fish in tank was more uniform in size than those in pond. The fish in the pond were larger in size (20.0cm) when compared to fish reared in tank facility. This could be due to the availability of natural food (plankton) induced by decomposed and degraded uneaten artificial feed for fish in the pond to consume. In the tank, the fish relied solely on artificial feed as the only food source.
Adebayo and Adesoji (2008) reported that Clarias gariepinus reared in earthen pond and concrete tank facilities of same size, 10x10x1.5m3 gave a profit of
N73, 000 and N52, 000 for pond and tank respectively. In this study, realizing higher profit in pond culture than tank corroborated the observations of Adebayo and Adesoji (2008). The present study has also shown that the type of culture medium used and its management could have a significant influence on fish profitability as similarly reported by Ross and Waten (1995). The concrete tank had a better Benefit : Cost ratio probably due to low cost in construction, good fish condition and growth, cheaper practice and the farmer being in full control when compared to the pond condition as observed in this study. For larger operations, the pond might be considered while in smaller practices the tank could be of choice. The net profit of N4, 300 recorded in pond and tank (N2, 250) showed that fish culture practice in the pond could be more profitable and appears to be a favourable financial potential for commercial production of Clarias gariepinus.
The values of temperature, DO and other observed water quality parameters monitored for 56days were within acceptable ranges for fish culture practice in this study (Boyd, 1982). This factor probably enhanced the observed good growth and condition of the test fish throughout the experimental period.
Clarias gariepinus is an economically important fish and its culture should be encouraged because it attracts premium price and is accepted by consumers. The use of earthen pond as a culture medium for C. gariepinus appears more favourable than tank for intensive and commercial venture under proper management. However, the tank culture system could be of choice for smaller operations.
Abdullah AY (2007): Evaluation of Fish Farming Potentials in Nigeria. An Approach Through the use of Geographic Information System (GIS). Ph.D Thesis. University of Abuja, 168p.
Adebayo IA, Adesoji SA (2008): Comparative Assessment of the Profit Margin of Catfish Reared in Concrete Tank and Earthen Pond. African J. of Agric. Res., 3(10): 677-680.
Adewolu MA, Ogunsanmi AO, Yunusa A (2008): Studies on Growth Performance and Feed Utilization of Two Clariid Catfish and their Hybrid Reared Under Different Culture Systems. European J. of Sci. Res., 23(2):252-260.
Alatise SP, Otubusin SO (2006): Effect of different stocking densities on Production of Catfish (Clarias gariepinus) in Bamboo-net cage System. In: Ansa EJ, Anyanwu PE, Ayonoadu BW, Erondu ES and Deekae SN (Eds.). Proc. of 20th Conf. of FISON at Port Harcourt, 14th-18th Nov., 2005, pp. 24-29.
Atanda AN (2007): Freshwater Fish seed resources in Nigeria. Assessment of Fresh water Fish Seed Resources for Sustainable Aquaculture. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper No. 501, Rome, 628p.
Ayinla OA (1985): Induced Spawning Trials of Clarias gariepinus. In: Proc. of 13th Annual Conf. of FISON, New Bussa, Nigeria, pp. 106-112.
Bagenal TB, Tesch FW (1978): Age and Growth. In: Bagenal T. (Ed.). Methods for Assessment of Fish Production in Fresh waters, 3rd Edn. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Osney Mead, Oxford, pp. 101-136.
Bard J, Dekimpe P, Lazard J, Lessent P, Lemasson J (1976): Handbook of Tropical Fish Culture Centre Technique Forester. Tropical 45bis, Avenned Labelled Garille 94130-Nogent Surmarine France. Ed. Ministry of Foreign Affairs, pp. 67-92.
Boyd CE (1982): Water Quality Management for Pond Fish Culture/ Elsevier Scientific Publ. Company. New York, 318p.
Brown ME (1957): Experimental Studies of Growth. In:Brown ME (Ed.). Physiology of Fishes. Academic Press, New York, Vol. 1, pp. 361-400.
Dada AA, Wonah CO (2003): Production of Exotic Clarias gariepinus at Varying Stocking Densities in Outdoor Concrete Ponds. J. of Aquatic Sci., 18(1):21-24.
Dambo WB, Rana KJ (1992): Effects of Stocking Densities on Growths and Survival of Oreochromis niloticus fry in the Hatchery. FAO Fish. Rep., 44(4): 353-356.
Duncan DB (1995): Multiple Range and Multiple F-Test. Biometrics, 11:1-42.
FDF. (1990): Fisheries Statistics of Nigeria, 2nd Edn. Federal Department of Fisheries, Abuja, Nigeria, 31p.
FDF. (1996): Federal Department of Fisheries. In: Eyo AA, and Ayanda JO (Eds.). Proc. of 18th Annual Conf. of FISON, pp. 200-203.
Hankins JA, Summarfelt ST, Durrant MD (1995): Impacts of Feeding and Stock Management Strategies upon Fish Production within Water Recycle Systems. In: Timmons MB (Ed.), Aquaculture Engineering and Waste management. Northeast Regional Agriculture Engineering Service. Ithaca, New York, pp. 70-89.
Hogendoorn H (1979): Controlled Propagation of the African Catfish, Clarias lazera (C&V) 1. Reproductive Biology and Field Experiments. Aquaculture, 17 (4): 323-333.
Kamthorn P, Miller J (2006): Manvel on Catfish Hatchery and Production. A Guide for Small to Medium Scale Hatchery and Farm Producers in Nigeria. Aquaculture and Inland Fisheries Project (AIFP). National Programme for Food Security (NSPES), 29p.
Mazid MA, Zaher M, Begum NN, Aliu MZ, Nahav F (1997): Formulation of Cost Effective Feeds from locally Available ingredients for Carp Polyculture System for Increased Production. Aquaculture, 151: 71-78.
Miller JW, Atanda AN (2004): Inventory of Fish Farms in Nigeria. Aquaculture and Inland Fisheries Project, National Special Programme for Food Security. 148p.
Okoye FC, Eyo AA, Aminu NG (2001): Growth of Tilapia Oreochromis niloticus Hybrid Fingerlings Fed Lipid Based Diets. In: Eyo AA (Ed.). Proc. of the 1st National Symp. on Fish Nutrition and Fish Feed Tech. of FISON, NIOMR Lagos, 26th-29th Oct., 1999, pp. 25-27.
Omitoyin BO (2007): Introduction to Fish Farming in Nigeria. Ibadan University Press, Publishing House, University of Ibadan, Nigeria, pp. 35-40.
Ross RM, Waten BJ (1995): Importance of Rearing-unit Design and Stocking Density on the Behaviours, Growth and Metabolism of Lake Trout (Salvelinus namaysuch). Aquaculture Engineering, pp. 40-45.
Utne F (1979): Standard Methods and Terminology on FinFish Nutrition. In: Halver JE and Trews K (Eds.). Fish Nutrition and Finfish Technologies H Heinemasn Gobh and C. Borkin, Vol. 11:437-444.
Wahua TAT (1999): Applied Statistics for Scientific Studies. Afrika-Link Press, 356p.
Cite this Article: Keremah RI, Esquire J, 2014. Comparative Assessment of Growth Performance and Economics of Production of Clarias gariepinus Fingerlings in Ponds and Tanks. Greener Journal of Agricultural Sciences. 4(2):034-038, http://dx.doi.org/10.15580/GJAS.2014.2.041513577.