|
Greener Journal of Educational
Research Vol. 9(2), pp. 116-125, 2019 ISSN: 2276-7789 Copyright ©2019, the copyright of
this article is retained by the author(s) DOI Link: https://doi.org/10.15580/GJER.2019.2.101319184 https://gjournals.org/GJER |
|
Retaining
Teenage Girls in Kenya: The Effect of Provision of Sanitary Pads in Ainamoi Sub-County Primary Schools, Kericho
County
University of Kabianga,
Kenya
|
ARTICLE INFO |
ABSTRACT |
|
Article No.: 101319184 Type: Research DOI: 10.15580/GJER.2019.2.101319184 |
Teenage years of
every child are challenging emotionally, physically and psychological
especially for the girl child. Studies have indicated that one out of ten
girls miss school in Africa during their menstruation periods and eventually
drop out as a result. This is due to lack of sanitary towels which the
Kenyan Government started providing since 2011. This study sought to
determine the effects of provision of sanitary pads on retention of teenage
girls before and after the provision of sanitary pads in primary schools.
This study adopted liberal feminist theory. A conceptual framework was also
formulated. The independent variable was provision of sanitary pads while
the dependent variable was retention of teenage girls in primary schools in Ainamoi Sub County, Kericho
County. Comparative and ex-post facto research design was adopted. Study population was 99 head teachers and
686 teenage girls. The sample size was 20 head teachers and 140 teenage
girls. Data was collected in the form of focus group discussion,
questionnaires’ and document analysis to get data on girls’ attendance.
Quantitative data was analyzed in the form of descriptive and inferential
statistics. While qualitative data was analyzed using themes and sub themes.
The study established that there was a strong negative relationship between
the provision of sanitary pads and retention of girls in school with a
coefficient of -0.724 accounted for 52.42% of the variation. The study
concluded that provision of sanitary pads has reduced absenteeism among the
girls in primary schools in Ainamoi sub-County, Kericho Count, hence improving teenage girls’ retention
in schools. The study recommended that sanitary pads be provided to all
teenage girls both in primary schools and secondary to improve on girl child
retention in school. The findings of this study are significant to
stakeholders in education guiding them on ways of improving teenage girls’
retention in the school. |
|
Submitted: 13/10/2019 Accepted: 22/10/2019 Published: |
|
|
*Corresponding Author Viviline
Ngeno E-mail: vivilinengeno@ yahoo.com |
|
|
Keywords: |
|
|
|
|
INTRODUCTION
Teenage years are the most difficult time in
the life of child and more difficult for the girl child as they are full of
psychological and emotional challenges. Sommer, (2009) states that there is an
increase in girl dropout rates around menarche because menarche marks the transition
to womanhood, which comes with bigger responsibilities and restrictions as well
as the possibility of becoming pregnant and married. It is also a very
uncomfortable time for the girls. A school going girl misses 5 school days a
month totaling to 60 days in a year. These are many days in terms of
syllabus coverage. This has an effect on the girls’
education leading to repetition among them and eventually dropout from school. According
to United Nations (2010), menstruation is an integral and normal part of human
life, indeed of human existence. Menstrual hygiene is fundamental to the
dignity and wellbeing of women and girls and an important part of the basic
hygiene, sanitation and reproductive health services to which every woman and
girl has a right. It further gives the statistics that globally, approximately
52% of the female population (26% of the total population) is of reproductive
age. Most of these women and girls will menstruate each month for between two
and seven days.
As per the United Nations(2010),
The subject of menstruation, however, is
too often taboo, and has many negative cultural attitudes associated with it,
including the idea that menstruating women and girls are ‘contaminated’,
‘dirty’ and ‘impure’. This mainly affects women and girls in rural settings and
in particular girls Some of the problems they face are: inadequate preparations
for young girls not yet experiencing menstrual hygiene, lack of or inadequate
water to clean and wash the body, lack of materials for managing menstrual hygiene,
no private space and wash rooms and inappropriate facilities for disposal of
materials for those who have used pads. This affects psychologically and
emotionally since it leaves them in a bad state.
The basic education
Act (2016) placed the responsibility of providing free, sufficient and quality
sanitary towels on the government in order to reduce the number of girls
missing school during their menstrual cycle. Due to the challenges the girls
are facing the Kenyan government funded and supplied to schools’ sanitary pads
since 2011 to boost girls’ access to education. In 2017/2018 financial year the
government budgeted 5 million to purchase sanitary pads by the government.
Research
Objective
The objective of the present research was to
determine the effect of provision of sanitary pads on retaining teenage girls
in the schools of Ainamoi Sub County, Kericho County
Synthesis off the Literature on
Students’ Academic Achievement
Education is very important and the learners
should be very comfortable so that they are able to pursue without any
interaction. sUNICEF (2011), indicated that in
southern Indian state of Tamil Nadu culturally as in many other parts of India,
menstruation is considered dirty and impure and during periods girls are
discouraged to attend school and stay at homes.
This is majorly because of unavailability of sanitary pads, inadequate
sanitation and absence of separate toilet for girls in schools, compounds the
problem and has a huge impact on girls’ school attendance and is a major reason
for dropout. World
Bank, (2017) in the article education for global development estimates that one
in ten girls in Sub-Saharan Africa misses school during their menstrual cycle.
By some estimates, this equals as much as twenty percent of a given school
year.
In a study done in Malawi, one-third of female students reported missing
at least one day of school during their previous menstrual period, the data
suggested that menstruation accounts only for a small proportion of all female
absenteeism and does not create a gender gap in absenteeism. (Population
Council, 2017). Oster & Thornton, (2010) estimated that girls miss about 0.4 days of
school in a 180-day school year due to their period. Moreover, using a
randomized evaluation we argue that providing better sanitary products has no
impact on closing this small attendance gap in developing countries. A Pilot Study on Sanitary Pad
Interventions for Girls' Education in Ghana proved that after 3 months,
providing pads with education significantly improved attendance and in five
months it improved performance among participants (Montgomery et al, 2012).
Study done on
menstrual management in Uganda by (UN, 2010) revealed that currently the means
of coping for girl pupils is the use of old cloth, dirty napkins and other
un-hygienic materials. While some schools have provided sanitary pads ranging
from sophisticated imported pads to locally manufactured pads by AfriPads and/or Makapads. In some
cases, parents provide the pads to the girls.
Kimondo (2007)
noted that the Net Enrolment Ratio (NER) for boys and girls is 93.01%; however,
55% of boys and 54.6% of girls reach primary four, while 31.2% of the boys and
27.7% of girls reach primary seven. Arguably, the problem of pupil dropout is
quite unsettling especially to policy makers. This is partly because it
reflects on the inadequacy of a schooling system in terms of either school
quality or quantity. In effect, school dropouts are usually associated with
high unemployment levels, low earnings, and poor health outcomes and persistent
poverty.
A study done in Kenya
by Ngayila, L and Zani, A.
(2014) revealed that lack of sanitary towels contributes to class absenteeism among
adolescent girls, there are other menstruation related concerns that force
adolescents stay out of class. Major authorities on the subject think that lack
of sanitary towels among school going girls is a major cause of poor
performance in schools due to abdominal and/or back pain, bad smell from
menstruation, and fear of ridicule from others after soiling clothes can also
contribute to poor performance. Girls attending mixed with feared to be mocked
by boys were also leading to school absenteeism. The study also found out that
the students have a general understanding of what menstruation entails, but
their attitudes differ depending on their social interpretation of menstruation
derived from their environments.
A qualitative study
done on teachers and students in Kisumu district by Jewitt
and Ryley, (2014) on “It’s a girl thing:
Menstruation, School Attendance, Spatial Mobility and Wider Gender Inequalities”
in Kenya revealed that improved access could address some key emotional and practical problems underlying girls’ absenteeism.
Especially important is their role in reducing the risk of shame/embarrassment
from visible menstrual leaks, which in turn helps girls to concentrate better
and feel more confident as well as allowing them greater spatial mobility
within and outside school. This study further indicated that girl’s absenteeism
was due menstrual periods. Although the term ‘sickness’ was used it soon
became apparent in our FGs that many girls also used it as a euphemism for
menstrual cramps and menstruation more generally.
According to Zana Africa the girls in Kenya use very unhygienic ways
during their menstrual periods. They used old blankets, rugs and other
materials. This proves to be a problem to the girls’ health. Zana Africa was founded to respond to the reality that
nearly one million girls in Kenya do not go to school because they lack access
to sanitary pads and corresponding reproductive health education. Zana Africa takes a three-pronged programmatic approach to
supporting girls: creating health education, delivering pads and education through local partners, and leading policy and advocacy. There is
sufficient evidence indicating that primary school dropout has escalated from
up to 6.1% in 2012. This requires intervention from all stakeholders. Philip, P
et al (2015), did a study in Kenya that involved 3000 women. The study revealed
that 1 in 10 girls were having sex to pay for sanitary ware. This is risky on
the part of the girls because of pregnancies and diseases such sexually
transmitted diseases and HIV/AIDS. The girls are disadvantaged especially if
they cannot afford the basic needs like sanitary pads. Men take advantage of
them when they are in need.
Wang’anya A, (2018)
in the study entitled “The effects of provision of sanitary
towels on performance of adolescent girls’ in primary schools in Kenya: A case
of Matungu Sub-County, Kaka mega County” found that
87% and 81% of the girls are always in school during their menses and always
present in school respectively and 40% absent from school for various reasons
with only 9% attributed to lack of sanitary towels. There was a progressive
increase in transition rates from lower to upper classes with 88% agreeing to
concentrate on their study activities. Happiness (43%) and shyness (56%) was also
reported by them. Self-confidence and being confident was at 61% and 78% while
81% were comfortable in class during their menses. Majority of the girls (85%) could
freely participate in class while 82% relate well with the peers and 68% mingle
freely with their classmates both boys and girls. Overall 72% admitted that
there is adequate provision of sanitary towels.
Theoretical
framework
Liberal
Feminism Theory
Liberal feminism is a
conventional perspective of the three gender theories. It stems from the idea
that women must obtain equal opportunities and equal rights in society (Acker
1987, Stromquist 1990a, Phillips 1987, and others).
Stereotyping and discrimination have created a situation where women have less
chance of education, fewer career opportunities, and other social dimensions in
society. It argues for better
allocation of resources so that women can obtain a fair share of educational
opportunities. Three major points of focus in the discourse of liberal feminism
are 1) equal opportunities;2) socialization and sexual
stereotyping; and 3) sexual discrimination (Acker 1987:423).This functionalist
view enforces the idea that schooling is meritocratic and that success in it
depends primarily on the motivation and the intellectual ability of the
individual. Therefore, this view of feminism does not aspire to change society;
rather it aims at improving the situation within the present system, i.e.
Western industrialized society (Stromquist 1990a).
School and education are considered to be positive and good, and improvements
are to be made within the existing system. Strategies include attempts to
increase access, such as promotion of `good practice', e.g. The Equal
Opportunities Commission (Acker1987) and training to change attitudes of
teachers and pupils/students (Weiner 1986). Liberal feminism is based on the
assumption that schooling is positive and improves women's welfare. Social
evolution is assumed and the state is perceived as a benevolent actor which
provides services and goods for the benefit of the people (Stromquist
1990a).Gordon (1996) argues that the state has perpetuated the educational
inequality by legislation and educational policy and practice both during the
colonial and independent Zimbabwe. Liberal feminisms criticized for ignoring
patriarchy, power and the systematic subordination of women (O'Brien 1983,
Weiner 1986, Acker 1987) as well as the effects of race and class (Arnot 1982, Acker 1987). Socialist feminism attempts to
address some of these problems. This study found the theory relevant since it
was focusing on the provision of sanitary pads in Kenyan primary schools to
retain the girl child in school. By providing the sanitary pads it is a way of
liberating the girls to access education without distractions like the boys.
Conceptual
Framework
Education is a form of investment in human
capital that yields economic benefits and contributes to a country’s future
wealth by increasing the productivity capacity of its people (Woodhall, 2004). Retaining the girl child in school is very
important because they will be able to be better leaders, workers and mothers.
For these to be achieved the government came up with an intervention by providing
sanitary pads to reduce absenteeism and dropout. Therefore, the conceptual
framework was based on the concept of investment choices advanced by Psacharopolous and Woodhall
(1985). Thus, the study adapted the concept to make it suitable for this study.
The independent variable was provision of sanitary pads while the dependent
variable is retention in school.

Figure
1: Conceptual Framework showing the sanitary pad as an independent variable and
girl child retention as dependent variable in Kericho
County, Kenya.
This conceptual framework helped to focus on
independent variables and dependent variables. The independent variable was
sanitary pads while the dependent is retention of girl child. The students
before provision of sanitary towels were used as a control group. The girl
child absenteeism determined before and after provision of sanitary towels.
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
Ex post
facto,
descriptive survey and comparative research designs were used in this study. Ex post facto research design seeks to
discover possible causes of behaviour, which has
already occurred and cannot be manipulated (Gall, Gall
& Borg, 2007). For the purpose of this study ex-post facto research design allowed the researcher to get all the
relevant information on absenteeism among the primary girls in class eight
before and after provision of sanitary pads in Ainamoi
sub county, Kericho County. This was done through use
of relevant documents like school registers. Comparative Research design is
used together with historical research to compare people’s experience of
different societies, either between times in the past or in parallel situations
in the present (Creswell, J.W, 2009). This was also adopted in the study.
Descriptive survey research design involves careful description of education
phenomena and reports the way things are. The descriptive survey is able to
explore the relationship between variables in their natural setting as they
occur (Leedy &Ormrod,
2005). The design was appropriate because it allowed the use of questionnaires
and interviews schedules as research instruments for collecting data at a given
point in time.
The study was done in Ainamoi sub- county, Kericho County. It is situated in the southern part of the
Rift Valley province. It lies between longitude 35°E and 35°50'E and
latitude 00 and 0°30'S. It
borders the following counties; Nandi to the North, Uasin
Gishu and Baringo to the
North East, Nakuru to the East and South East, Bomet to the south, Nyamira and Homa-Bay to the South West and Kisumu County to the West
and North West. It covers an area of 2,479
; the capital of the County is Kericho town. Kericho
County consists of five sub counties Ainamoi, Belgut, Bureti, Londiani and
Kipkelion. The study was conducted in Ainamoi sub-county and it has 99 primary schools.
The study
population consisted of 99 primary school head teachers and 99 class 686 girls
were used in the study. According Mugenda and Mugenda, (2003) a sample size of 10% - 30% is a good
representation of the study population. Therefore .this study adopted 20% of
the population. The number of the head
teacher and girls Sampled were 19.8 and 137.2. The numbers were then rounded to
20 head teachers and 140 girls. The closed
and open-ended questionnaire was administered to each school head teachers from
the selected 20 schools. The girls took part in focus group discussion. Twenty
percent for each school were selected so that they all have equally
opportunities depending on the school enrolment.
The instruments that
were in the study was questionnaire, and Document
Analysis Guide. The instruments were validated. Validity of a measurement
instrument is the extent to which the instrument measures what it is supposed
to measure. Reliability of a measurement instrument is the extent to which it
yields consistent results when the characteristic being measured has not
changed. Like validity, reliability takes different forms in different
situations (Leedy & Ormrod,
2005). Reliability of the instrument was 0.8 at a set p-value of 0.05. This
means the instrument was reliable as the calculated coefficient was greater
than 0.7. (Mugenda & Mugenda, 2003). Qualitative data was analyzed using
themes and sub themes. While quantitative data was analyzed using descriptive
in form of percentages while inferential statistic was analyzed using Pearson
product moment correlation. It was then interpreted using the guide given by Elfison, Runyon and Haber (1990) as given in table 1.
PEARSON
CORRELATION COEFFICIENCY
Correlation coefficients (r) were therefore
interpreted to determine the influence of FSE policy on the dependent variables
in terms of direction and strength of relationship Elfison,
Runyon and Haber (1990) interpretation
guideline was adopted (Table 1).
Table 1: Interpretation
of Pearson Correlation Coefficients (r)
|
Strength of the relationship |
Positive (+) |
Negative (-) |
|
Weak/low/small |
0.01
– 0.30 |
0.01
– 0.30 |
|
Moderate/ medium |
0.31
– 0.70 |
0.31
– 0.70 |
|
Strong/high |
0.71
– 0.99 |
0.71
– 0.99 |
|
Perfect relationship |
1.00 |
1.00 |
|
No relationship |
0.00 |
0.00 |
From Table 1 it can be observed that Pearson (r) between + or - 0.01 – 0.30 is a
weak/low/small relationship, between + or - 0.31 – 0.70 is a moderate/medium,
while relationship between + or - 0.71 – 0.99 is a strong/high relationship.
Perfect relationship is where it is positive or negative 1.00 while 0.00 means
there is no relationship. Coefficient of determination R2 is the square of the Pearson r which tells how much of the variance is accounted for by the
correlation which is expressed in percentages while the other remaining
percentage could be due to other factors (Leedy &
Ormond, 2005). This was adopted in the interpretation of Pearson (r) and coefficient of determination R2 in this study.
RESEARCH
FINDINGS
Return
Rate of the Questionnaire
The respondents in this study included
primary school head teachers and class (8) eight girls’ prefects.
The return rate of principals’ questionnaire
was as shown in Table 2.
Table 2: Return
Rate of the head teachers Questionnaire used for Data Collection
|
Respondents |
Issued |
Number Returned |
Percentage (%) |
|
Head teachers |
20 |
20 |
100 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Totals |
20 |
20 |
100 |
From Table 2 it can be observed that all
school head teachers returned the questionnaire as was required. The rate of
return for the questionnaires was 100%. This data on return rates helps to
justify the validity of the data that was used in this study and the new knowledge
generated.
Demographic
Characteristics of the Respondents
The respondents in this study included
primary school head teachers and class eight girls’ prefects. Their demographic
characteristics were as shown in Tables 3 and 4.
Table 3: Head
teachers Gender and Headship Experience
(n=20)
|
Demographic characteristics |
Frequency (f) |
Percentage (%) |
|
Gender |
|
|
|
Male |
12 |
60 |
|
Female |
8 |
40 |
|
Total |
20 |
100 |
|
Headship Experience in years |
|
|
|
5 |
1 |
5 |
|
6-10 |
5 |
25 |
|
11-15 |
9 |
45 |
|
16-20 |
5 |
25 |
|
Total |
20 |
100.00 |
Table 3 indicates that out of all the 20
(100%) school head teachers involved in the study 12 (60%) were male while 8
(40%) were female. This shows fewer female teachers are appointed as school
head teachers in Ainamoi sub county, Kericho County. This is in agreement with the study carried
out in a sampled number of schools in Kenya by Bosire et al (2009)
where it was indicated that out of the 30 sampled school principals, 22(79%)
were male while 6 (21%) were female. The school principals’ leadership
experience was also indicated and one (5%) had headship experience between 5
years, 5 (25%) had an experience of 6-10years, 9 (45%) had an experience of
11-15 years while 5 (25 %) had an experience of 16-20 years.
From the findings
most school head teachers had headship experience of 6 years
and above. This shows that they had enough experience in school management and
they were able to give the relevant information on influence of provision of
sanitary pads on girls’ retention in school. They were also better placed given
that the data required dated back to the year 2012 that required experience in
school administration.
Absenteeism Rates
among the Primary School Girls before Provision of Sanitary Pads
The research question responded to was: What
is effect of provision of sanitary pads on girl child retention in Primary
School?
The head teachers
through questionnaires were asked to indicate enrolments. Data obtained and
used to determine absenteeism for class eight was 2017. The cost of the sanitary
pads given by the school head teacher was 50/= Kenyan shilling per packet. The
cost of a packet of sanitary pads was multiplied by the number of girls who
were in class eight (2017 per school) to get the total cost incurred per child.
The cost was computed and correlated with the absenteeism rates to determine
the effect of provision of sanitary pads on retention. The results are
presented in the tables below.
Table 4: Absenteeism
rates per school before and after provision of sanitary pads in Ainamoi Sub-County, Kericho
County (n=20)
|
Absenteeism Rate |
Before provision |
After provision |
||
|
Frequency (f) |
Percentage (%) |
Frequency (f) |
Percentage (%) |
|
|
Below
0.20 |
1 |
5 |
17 |
85 |
|
0.21-0.40 |
5 |
25 |
2 |
10 |
|
0.41-0.60 |
6 |
30 |
1 |
5 |
|
0.61-0.80 |
5 |
25 |
0 |
0 |
|
Above
0.81 |
3 |
15 |
0 |
0 |
|
Total |
20 |
100 |
20 |
100 |
Table 4 indicates the girls’ absenteeism
rates per schools before and after the provision of sanitary pads in 2011.
Before the sanitary pads were provided by the Kenyan government the percentage
of the girls who were absent from school was high as compared to after. One (5%)
school, had absenteeism rate below 0.20, 5(25%) of the schools had the rates
between 0.21 and 0.40, 6(30%) had the absenteeism rates from 0.41 to 0.60.
While 5(25%) of the schools had the absenteeism rates ranging from 0.61 to
0.08. Three (15%) schools had the rates above 0.81.
After the provision of sanitary pads
absenteeism rates reduced in all the schools. The school that had the rates
below 20 were 17(85%), two (10) had the rates from 0.21 to 0.40 while one (5%)
school had the rate from 0.41 to 0.60. this indicates that sanitary pads played
a big role in reducing absenteeism rates in schools.
Table 5: Girls
Absenteeism Rates before and after the Provision of Sanitary Pads in Kenya
(n=20)
|
Before provision of sanitary pads |
After provision of sanitary pads |
|||
|
|
Frequency (f) |
Percentages (%) |
Frequency (f) |
Percentages (%) |
|
Present |
308 |
57.57 |
600 |
87.46 |
|
Absent |
295 |
42.43 |
86 |
12.54 |
|
Total |
603 |
100 |
686 |
100 |
Table 5 indicates the girls’ absenteeism
before and after the provision of sanitary pads in 2013 for all the 20 schools
in Ainamoi Sub-County, Kericho
County. The class eight girls were used in this study. Before the sanitary pads
were provided the girls, who remained in school were 308 (57.57%) while those
who were absent from school because of lack of sanitary pads were 295 (42.43
%). After the sanitary pads were
provided the girls who were retained in school were 600 (87.46%) while those
who were absent were 86 (12.54%).
The finding reveals
that after the provision of sanitary pads absenteeism among the girls reduced
by 29.89 %. This is a big improvement on the girls’ education. This does not
agree with the study by Oster & Thornton, (2010) that indicated that girls miss about 0.4
days of school in a 180-day school year due to their period. Further evaluation
indicated that providing better sanitary products has no impact on closing this
small attendance gap in developing countries.
But this concurs with a Pilot Study on Sanitary Pad Interventions for
Girls' Education in Ghana by Montgomery et al, (2012) proved that after 3
months, providing pads with education significantly improved attendance and in
five months it improved performance among participants.
This is also in
agreement with World Bank, (2017) article on education for global development
estimates that one in ten girls in Sub-Saharan Africa missed school during
their menstrual cycle. By some estimates, this equals as much as twenty percent
of a given school year. This is a very high percentage in terms of syllabus coverage, but does concur with the study done
in Malawi. One-third of female students reported missing at least 1 day of
school during their previous menstrual period. The data suggested that
menstruation accounts only for a small proportion of all female absenteeism and
does not create a gender gap in absenteeism. (Population
Council, 2017). This is in agreement with the study done by Wang’anya A, (2018) on the effects
of provision of sanitary towels on performance of adolescent girls’ in primary
schools in Matungu Sub-County, Kakamega
County. The study findings revealed that
87% and 81% of the girls were always in school during their menses and always
present in school respectively and 40% were
absent from school for various reasons with only 9% attributed to lack of
sanitary towels. This is an indication that sanitary pads can improve girl child retention in
school.
Table 6: Cost
Incurred by the Government per School in Ainamoi
Sub-County, Kericho County (n=20)
|
Costs of sanitary pads Kenya Shillings (KSH) |
Schools |
|
|
Frequency (f) |
Percentage (%) |
|
|
501-1000 |
2 |
10 |
|
1001-1500 |
9 |
45 |
|
1501-2000 |
4 |
20 |
|
2001-2500 |
3 |
15 |
|
2501-3000 |
2 |
10 |
|
Total |
20 |
100 |
Table 6 indicates the cost incurred by the
government per school for all the class 8 girls’ that were used for the study.
The cost per packet used was KSH50 as given by school head teachers. The costs
were multiplied by the number of girls to get the total cost incurred by the
government per school. The cost was high for schools with more girls. The
schools that the government incurred cost from 501 to 1000 were 2(10%), from 1001 to 1500 were 9(45%) for a range of 1501 to 2000
were 4(20%). While between 2001 to 2500 and 2501 and 3000 were 3(15%) and
2(10%) respectively.
The finding in table 4 on the absenteeism
rate and the costs incurred per school in Table 6 were correlated using Pearson
Product Moment Correlation to get the effect of sanitary pads on absenteeism
and retention. The correlation matrix is presented in Table 7.
Table 7: Pearson
Product Moment Correlation (r) sanitary pads and Absenteeism among the girls in
Ainamoi Sub County (n=20)
|
|
Funds |
Absenteeism rates |
|
|
Funds |
Pearson Correlation |
1 |
-.724** |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
|
.000 |
|
|
N |
20 |
20 |
|
|
Absenteeism Rate |
Pearson Correlation |
-.724** |
1 |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
.000 |
|
|
|
N |
20 |
20 |
|
|
**. Correlation is significant at the
0.01 level (2-tailed). |
|||
Table 7 indicates that there is a negative
strong significant relationship with a coefficient of -0.724 between the
amounts incurred on sanitary pads and absenteeism rates. According
to Elfison, Runyon and Haber (1990); Leedy and Ormrod (2005),
guideline Correlation coefficients (r) interpretation. Coefficient of
determination R2 is the
square of the Pearson’s r which tells
how much of the variance is accounted for by the correlation which is expressed
in percentages (Leedy & Ormrod,
2005). To account for the effect of sanitary pads on absenteeism Pearson’s r was squared. The coefficient of
determination R2 = 0.524
which meant that sanitary pads influenced absenteeism negatively. It accounted
for 52.42% of the variation in absenteeism.
DISCUSSION
Causes of
Absenteeism
The
girls gave further information on what affects their attendance. It was in
agreement with what was revealed by the quantitative data.
House hold chores and
other family problems was indicated by the majority of
the girl that it has an influence on their attendance. Since most of the
primary schools are day schools the girls face problems related to family. This
concurs with the studies done by Ngeno et al (2013)
which revealed that family problems have an effect on the girls schooling.
Lack of sanitary pads
was given by all the girls as one of the reasons their class mates avoid coming
to school. This is because the girls feel embarrassed when they soil their
clothes. In fact, one of the girls started that some girls are even embarrassed
by their classmates’ especially the boys. This makes them avoid school for a
while. This is in agreement with the studies done by Sommer, (2009) that states there is an
increase in girl dropout rates around. it further
revealed that a school going girl misses 5 school days a month totaling to 60
days in a year. This is a very high percentage in terms of syllabus
coverage. This has an effect on the girls’
education leading to repetition among them and eventually dropout from school.
It
also concurs with the study done by UNICEF, (2011) in southern Indian state of Tamil
Nadu. This revealed that culturally in many other parts of India, menstruation
is considered dirty and impure and during periods girls are discouraged to
attend school and asked to stay at homes. Studies done by
Population Council, (2017) and Oster & Thornton, (2010) in Malawi
and Ghana respectively found that one-third of female students reported missing
school while in Ghana the girls missed 0.4 days of school in a 180-day
school year due to their period. It also concurs with studies done in Kenya by Ngayila, L and Zani, A. (2014) in
their findings that indicate that lack of sanitary towels contributes to class
absenteeism among adolescent girls. There are other menstruation related
concerns that force adolescents to stay out of class.
Sickness was also one of
the factors the girls mentioned as the factor that influence absenteeism among
the girls in primary schools. Though sickness among the girls
can be related to monthly periods. When a child is sick it difficult for
them to concentrate so most of them stay at home until they are well. This is
in agreement with study by Kimondo (2007) in which he found that school dropouts are
usually associated with high unemployment levels, low earnings, and poor health
outcomes, persistent poverty. This is in agreement with the study done on
teachers and students in Kisumu district by Jewitt
and Ryley, (2014) on it’s a girl thing: This study further
indicated that girl’s absenteeism was due to menstrual periods. Although the term ‘sickness’ was
used it soon became apparent in our FGs that many girls also used it as a
euphemism for menstrual cramps and menstruation more generally.
What the
Girls used before Provision of Sanitary Pads
The girls were further asked to give information on what they used when
sanitary pads were not available.
All the girls mentioned
that they used blankets and old rugs during their menstrual cycle. They were used
as they could be
recycled next time. This could solve their problem though in terms of hygiene
it may not be good. This is in agreement with the study done by Zana Africa that
revealed that the
girls in Kenya used very unhygienic ways during their menstrual periods use of
old blankets, rugs and other materials are used. This proves to be a problem to
the girls’ health.
Sanitary pads were
used by very few girls bought by the parents. This is because majority of the
girls could not afford. Some of the girls rely on their boyfriend to purchase
for them but after engaging in sexually activity. This could also be risking
their lives because of pregnancies and diseases like HIV/AIDS. Some of the
stated the way their friends are lured into sexually activities because of
desperation. This concurs with the study done in Kenya by Philip,
(2015), that involved 3000 women. The study revealed that 1 in 10 girls were
having sex to pay for sanitary ware. This is risky on the part of the girls
because of pregnancies and diseases such sexually transmitted diseases and
HIV/AIDS.
Some of the young and
innocent girls used nothing, especially those who have not been informed about
the monthly periods and it’s their first time. This leaves the girls in shock
since it’s the first time they are experiencing such. This is due to lack of
information. These findings are in agreement with the study done in Uganda by UN, (2010) revealed that some of
the problem facing young girls in rural settings is inadequate preparations for
young girls not yet experiencing menstrual hygiene. This led to these girls
using nothing hence soiling their clothes. This affects the girls
psychologically and emotional because of embarrassment and the feeling that the
other children are laughing at them.
Tissue paper and other papers were used by a few students
who manage to get it. These girls would reach a desperate state to an extent
that they try to use anything to stop or absorb the menstrual flow. This is in
agreement with the study done in Uganda by (UN, 2010) where the girls used,
dirty napkins and other un-hygienic materials.
Effects of Provision of Sanitary Pads
The girls
were further asked to give their opinion on how provision of sanitary pads have
influenced absenteeism
Most of the girls explained that class attendance has really improved.
This is in agreement with the basic education Act (2016) when it placed
the responsibility of providing free, sufficient and quality sanitary towels on
the government in order to reduce the number of girls missing school during
their menstrual cycle. This is in agreement with the study done in by Wang’anya A, (2018) on the effects
of provision of sanitary towels on performance of adolescent girls’ in primary
schools in Kenya: a case of Matungu Sub-County, Kaka
mega County. The study findings revealed girls attended school has normalized
now after the provision of sanitary pads. This is because the girls are always
in school during their menses and always present in class. That has led them to
be at per with the rest in terms of syllabus coverage.
Improved hygiene was also mentioned by most of the girls. The girls
mentioned during the focus group discussion that hygiene has improved since
they feel that they are clean unlike before when they would use any material.
In fact, one of the girls stated that, “I Feel I don’t smell during my menses,
this has given me confidence to interact with the other pupils even the boys”.
This is an indication that the girls are happy and more confident in school and
especially when they are with the rest.
Concentration and confidence have also improved among the girls. The
girls during focus group discussion explained how their concentration and
confidence have improve after the provision of
sanitary pads. This findings are in agreement with the study done by Wang’anya A, (2018)
on the effects of provision of sanitary towels on performance of adolescent
girls’ in primary schools in Matungu Sub-County, Kaka
mega County where it revealed that there was a progressive increase in
transition rates from lower to upper classes with 88% agreeing to concentrate
on their study activities. Happiness and shyness were 43% and 56%.
Self-confidence and being confident was at 61% and 78% while 81% were
comfortable in class during their menses. Majority of the girls at 85% can
freely participate in class while 82% relate well with the peers and 68% mingle
freely with their classmates both boys and girls
The girls further explained that they are able to participate in
various activities unlike when they don’t have sanitary pads and they feel very
insecure. This is good for the girls because with confidence they can achieve so
much and it also boost them academically. This finding is in agreement with the
finding in by Wang’anya A, (2018) on the
effects of provision of sanitary towels on performance of adolescent girls’ in
primary schools in Matungu Sub-County, Kakamega County where it revealed that the girls can freely
participate in all the other activities without fear. It revealed that Majority
of the girls at 85% can freely participate in class while 82% relate well with
the peers and 68% mingle freely with their classmates both boys and girls.
Overall 72% admit there is adequate provision of sanitary towels.
Adequate sanitary pads were also sighted by some girls in some schools
though there were a few schools the girls felt that at times they miss out on
sanitary pads. In fact, one of the girls explained the at
time they need sanitary pads but they are informed that it not available. This concurs with the study done in Kakamega by Wang’anya A, (2018)
where it revealed that 72% admit there is adequate provision of sanitary
towels. This has been of great help to the girl child and women generally.
CONCLUSIONS
The study concluded that provision of
sanitary pads has reduced absenteeism among the girls in primary schools in Ainamoi sub-County, Kericho
County. Hence improving teenage girls’ retention in schools.
The study recommended that sanitary pads be provided to all teenage girls both
in primary schools and secondary improve on girl child retention in school.
RECOMMENDATIONS
The study recommended that sanitary pads be
provided to all teenage girls both in primary schools and secondary improve on
girl child retention in school.
REFERENCES
Acker, S.
(1987). "Feminist
Theory and the Study of Gender and Education", International Review of
Education, 33 (4): 419-435.
Arnott, M. (1982) "Male Hegemony, Social Class and Women's
Education", Journal of Education,
164 (1): 64-89.
Coleman,
J.S., Campell, E, Q., Hosbon,
C.J., MC Partland, J., Mood, A.M., Weifeld, F.D and York, R, L (1966). Equality of educational opportunity, Washington, D.C. Government
printing office.
Creswell, J.W.
(2009). Research
Design, Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches. California SAGE
Publications.
E. Oster & R. Thornton, (2010). Menstruation, Sanitary Products and
School Attendance: Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation. American Economic
Journal: Applied Economics
Gall,
D.M., Gall, J.P. & Borg, R.W. (2007). Educational research, an
introduction. New York: Longman.
Gathigah, M. (2011). Kenya Parliament opts to Help
Girls with Sanitary Pads . Women
News Network (WNN); IPS; the Guardian Development Network. Retrieved from www.womennewsnetwork.net/2011/08/16/Kenya-sanitary-pads/
on January 19, 2012.
Gordon, R. (1996) “Legislation and Educational Policy in Zimbabwe: the state and the
reproduction of patriarchy” Gender and Education 8(2): 215-229.
Hanushek, E.A, (2008). Education Production
Functions. The New Palgave Dictionary of Economics,
2nd edition. Abstract. Basingtoke:
Palgrave Macmillan.
Hopkins, G . (1990). the poor
die young: housing and health. Earth Scan Publications,
London.
Jewitt, , S. & Ryley, H (2014). It’s a girl thing: Menstruation, school
attendance, spatial mobility and wider gender inequalities in Kenya.
Elsevier journal Geoforum. Volume 56,
September 2014, Pages 137–147
Liston, V. (2006). NGO’S
and Spatial Dimensions of Poverty in Kenya. Dublin: Department of Political Science, Trinity College.
Marlaine, L. and Hanushek,
E. (1988). Improving
Educational efficiency in developing countries.
Mugenda,
O.M. & Mugenda, A.G. (2003). Research Methods: Quantitative
and Qualitative Approaches. Nairobi: ACTS Press.
Ngayila, L and Zani, A. (2014). An Evaluation Of The Perception
Of Secondary School Students Towards Menstruation In Kenya. African
Journal of Education and Technology, Volume 4 Number 1 (2014), pp. 83-96
Ngeno, V.C., Simatwa, E.M.W. & Soi, D.C.
(2013). Determinants of Girl Students’ Academic Achievement in Mixed Day and
Boarding Secondary Schools in Kericho District: An
Analytical Study. Educational Research Journal.Vol. 4
(7):543-554. http://www.interesjournals.org/er/.
O'Brien, M. (1983) "Feminism and Education: A Critical Review Essay", Resources
for Feminist Research, 12 (3):3-16.
Phillips, P.A. at el (2011). Menstrual cups and sanitary pads to reduce
school attrition, and sexually transmitted and reproductive tract infections: a
cluster randomised controlled feasibility study in
rural Western Kenya
Pritchett, L and Filmer,
D (1997). What Education
Production functions Really show; a positive Theory of
Education expenditure. World bank.
Psacharapoulos, G. & Woodhall, M. (1985). Education
for development. An analysis of investment choices.
Washington D.C: Oxford University Press.
Sommer,
M. (2009).“Ideologies of sexuality, menstruation and
risk: Girls' experiences of puberty and schooling in northern Tanzania,
Culture, Health and Sexuality.” 11, no. 4 (2009): 383.
Stromquist, N. P. (1990a) "Gender Inequality in Education:
Accounting for Women's Subordination," British
Journal of Sociology of Education, 11 (2): 137-153.
UNICEF, (2011).
Menstrual Hygiene Key to Keeping Girls in School.
UNICEF, INDIA
http://www.unicef.in/Story/122/Menstrual-Hygiene-Key-to-Keeping-Girls-in-School
United
Nation, (2010). Study on
menstrual management in Uganda Main report on the study results. The
Netherlands Development Organization (SNV)/IRC International Water and
Sanitation Centre.
Wang’anya A, (2018) Effects of provision of sanitary towels on
performance of adolescent girls’ in primary schools in Kenya: A case of Matungu Sub-County, Kaka mega County. University
of Nairobi.
Woodhall, M. (2004). Analysis in
Educational Planning Cost Benefit
Analysis in Education. Paris: IIEP .UNESCO.
World Bank,
(2017). Education for Global
development. A blog about the power of investing in
people. World Bank Group. https://blogs.worldbank.org/education/globally-periods-are-causing-girls-be-absent-school
|
Cite this Article: Ngeno, V (2019). Retaining Teenage Girls in Kenya: The
Effect of Provision of Sanitary Pads in Ainamoi
Sub-County Primary Schools, Kericho County, 9(2): 116-125,
https://doi.org/10.15580/GJER.2019.2.101319184. |