By Lukong, TE
(2022)
|
Greener Journal of
Psychology and Counselling Vol. 4(1), pp. 01-17,
2022 ISSN: 2672-4502 Copyright ©2022, the
copyright of this article is retained by the author(s) |
|
Perceived Cognitive Strategies and the Acquisition of
Motor Mechanic Competency among Trainees of Auto Training Institutes in the Buea, Cameroon.
Dr.
Department of Educational Psychology, Faculty of
Education, University of Buea.
|
ARTICLE INFO |
ABSTRACT |
|
Article No.: 092322084 Type: Research |
This study was aimed at investigating perceived
cognitive strategies and the acquisition of motor mechanic competency among
trainees of auto training institutes in the Buea
Municipality. Four research objectives guided the study which was to find
out: The influence of cognitive strategies on diagnostic motor mechanic
competency, the influence of problem-solving strategies on the acquisition
of motor mechanic competency, the influence of technical skills on the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency and determine the influence of
inter-personal relationship on the acquisition of motor mechanic competency.
At the level of theories, Atkinson and Shriffrin’s
information processing (1968), Lev Vygotsky and
socio-cultural theory (1896-1934), John Flavel’s
metacognition theory (1978) and Albert Bandura observational learning theory
were used for the study. The study used the concurrent triangulation mixed
method where both qualitative and quantitative methods were used. The sample
population of this study comprised of thirty (30) apprentices in mechanic
garages and 10 trainers randomly selected from five garages namely; C.O.I.C,
great soppo, “Kilonomic
garage” mile 17, “Top ten” Molyko, “Fako Garage” Bonduma, and
“Faith Auto garage” Bokwai Junction. The sampling
technique used in this study was convenient sampling technique. The
instruments used for the collection of data were a questionnaire and
interview schedule. Descriptive data were analysed using tables,
percentages, and frequencies. Inferentially data were analysed via the
Product Moment Correlation. As for analysis of data from the interview, the
researcher used themetic analysis. The findings
revealed that a diagnostic strategy positively and significantly influences
the acquisition of motor mechanic competency. Problem solving strategies
positively but insignificantly influences the acquisition of motor mechanic
competency. A technical strategy positively and significantly influences
acquisition of motor mechanic competency. Inter-personal strategies
positively and insignificantly influence the acquisition of motor mechanic
competency. Based on the findings the following recommendations were made:
Government should assist in training roadside mechanics to upgrade their
knowledge and skills in the area of automotive electronics and Training
institutions and organizations such as the universities, polytechnics, Board
for Small Scale Industries etc., should assist particularly in the form of
education and training to equip roadside mechanics with the requisite skills
and technology to be able to work on the electronic managed vehicles. |
|
Accepted: 30/09/2022 Published: 16/10/2022 |
|
|
*Corresponding
Author Dr. Tani
Emmanuel Lukong E-mail: elukongt@ gmail.com |
|
|
Keywords: |
|
|
|
|
Cognitive
strategies are the specific methods and
skills that people use to solve problems and/or exploit opportunities, including all sorts of reasoning, and
planning, arithmetic (Blanchowicz & Ogle, 2001).
Importantly, a cognitive strategy need not be all "in the head", but
will almost always interact with various aspects of what might be called the
"execution context". A specific cognitive strategy could be
implemented in an ordered and overlapping manner. Each logical aspect of a
cognitive strategy is either taught or learned and needs to be remembered as
for the advancement of knowledge. These cognitive strategies are memorized for
future utilization. They can be thought of as consciously written and
remembered "programs" or as the "software" that guides
future brain-neuron processing. Each logic process helps to "add up"
to a specific decision and resulting action.
A commonly used and elegant example
of cognitive strategies comes from small-number addition (Anderson, 1990).
There are many different strategies by which one can get the sum of two, let's
say one digit numbers, for example 3+4 (=7). The way that most adults would
solve this problem is by simply remembering the answer (a "memory"
strategy), but a toddler would probably use one of a number of different
finger-counting strategies (Siegler & Shipley, 1995). For example, one can
represent the first addend (3) on one's left hand by raising three fingers, and
then do the same with four fingers on the right hand, and then count up the
number of fingers that are raised. But there are many other ways to do this.
For example, one can do the same first step (raise three fingers on one's left
hand), and then start counting from 4 as one raises four more fingers one at a
time on either the right hand, or even starting from the fourth finger on the
left hand (which would require continuing from 6 on the right hand). Different
strategies may have very different characteristics in terms of their time and
space complexity, memory requirements, etc., and
therefore in terms of their error characteristics.
With the increasing nature of the globalization of
science and technology, there are many car owners today in the society and the
main problem that arises is that of repairs and maintenance. There is therefore
need to apply appropriate cognitive strategies that will be used in learning
the motor mechanic skills (Clark & Graves, 2005). This paper therefore, examines the following cognitive strategies;
diagnostic strategies, problem solving strategies, practical strategies,
inter-personal and that will be used in the learning of motor mechanics (Panel
biting/bodyworks, electric work, general maintenance and engine repairs)
Prior to the formal study of cognitive strategies as a field of study or
course in school, it is important to mention that cognitive strategies were
visible during the African indigenous education. Three main methods were used
in learning as cognitive strategies namely; observation, imitation,
participation (Mac-ojong, 2008). Emphasis was on
learning and not on the teaching process. These three methods were used to
enable the child to developed interest on independent study sometimes not
requiring the presence of a teacher. Observation imitation and participation as
learning processes were in line with Bandura (1986) who emphasized learning by
observation and imitation of models. These processes enabled the child to
develop interest in learning even in the absence of the master. In this system
of education, knowledge was caught not taught. Masters or teachers in
indigenous, education included mothers who were assigned to teach female
children fathers who took care of male children, elders, sibling and elders in
the community. For instance, children observed their parents during farming,
they imitate them in whatever they were doing and after they learnt what they
had observed, they participate in the process.
Looking at the antecedent of cognitive strategies the first writer to
publish a work based on it was Ulric Neisser in his book called “Cognitive
psychology” in 1967 (Lavel, 1998). Neisser advanced a new way of looking at the human
mind. He held that memory, perception and other internal thought processes
could be studied and measured, work that was aided by growing computing power.
His ideas directly challenged behaviourism, the dominant school in psychology
in which Neisser had been trained, which examines responses to external
stimuli. Neisser showed that memory, no matter how certain we are of its
accuracy, is often only a partially accurate or
sometimes inaccurate reconstruction of past events.
In the late 1980s a number of North American Research Centres,
Institutes and University Departments working in the fields of cognition and
learning, concerns were expressed that current approaches in education were
insufficient and a new perspective on the education process was needed. The how
perspective advocated in a series of three key publications aiming to redraw
the educational landscape for the 1990s (Brown, Collins, Duguid, 1989; Collins,
Brown & Newman 1989; Lave & Wenger, 1991) outlined in the different
cognitive strategies used advocated by Collins & Brown (1989).
Prior to the learning of motor mechanic, it is important to mention how
the means of transport manifested. During the ancient times, man realized that
the means of transport with which nature had provided him left much to be
desired. He was severely limited in the loads he could carry, even without a
load. Furthermore, it is a safe guess that the physical exertion involved was
no more to his liking than it is today (McDonald, 2001).
The taming and training of suitable animals enabled heavier loads to be
carried greater distances, often at greater speeds then man was capable of
attaining, and there was added value advantage theta most of the effort was
provided by the animal, while the man could travel at his ease (Wiggins, &
Smith, 2005). Heavy loads were dragged upon sledges until an early and unknown
engineer invented the wheel. This made it possible to construct crude carts
upon which even heavier loads could be carried more easily. The one drawback to
the use of wheeled vehicles was and is still the necessity of providing a
reasonably smooth and hard surface upon which wheels could run. The development
of wheeled vehicles is closely related to the development of roads. However,
during these transitions there was need for appropriate maintenance and repairs
of these different means of transport, as such several cognitive strategies
like problem solving and technical-know how were employed in learning them.
As new materials and manufacturing methods were developed, it became
possible to make improvements in vehicles, but so long as animals were the only
form of motive power it was not possible to increase loads and speeds very much
(Neufeld, 2005). The development of the steam engine during the eighteenth and
nineteenth centuries led to its application to the driving of vehicles, and
though some of the early attempts were crude and not very stressful, several
extremely promising were crude and not very successful, several extremely
promising carriages were produced which might have been developed into very
practical vehicles had not restrictive legislation forced them off the roads.
The steam engine proved less suited to road vehicles than it did to the
railway. It was the successful development of the light high-speed
internal-combustion engine towards the end of the 19th century which really
opened up the way to the power-driven road vehicle, and which made possible the
development of the modern motor-car, lorry, bus and coach. Motor vehicles were
developed from horse-drawn carriages. They were, in fact, called “horseless
carriages” and naturally owed something of their general form to those
carriages (Keene, 2006). However, during these transitions there was need for
appropriate maintenance and repairs of these different means of transport, as
such several cognitive strategies like problem solving and technical-know how
were employed in learning them.
Conceptually,
cognitive strategies are
sets of mental processes that are consciously implemented to regulate thought
processes and content in order to achieve goals (Harrisson,
2007). According to Anderson &Siegler (2000), cognitive strategies are
the specific methods that people use to solve problems and/or exploit opportunities, including
all sorts of reasoning, planning, arithmetic, etc. Importantly, a cognitive
strategy need not be all "in the head", but will almost always
interact with various aspects of what might be called the "execution
context". A specific cognitive strategy would be implemented via a set of
ordered and overlapping logic. Each logical aspect of a cognitive strategy is
either taught or learned and needs to be remembered as situation foreknowledge.
These cognitive strategies are memorized for future utilization. They can be
thought of as consciously written and remembered "programs" or as the
"software" that guides future brain-neuron processing. Each logic
process helps to "add up" to a specific decision and resulting
action.
Different strategies may have different
characteristics in terms of their time and space complexity, memory
requirements, etc. and therefore in terms of their error characteristics. These
different cognitive strategies can be employed in the learning of different
skills. Cognitive strategies are useful tools in assisting
students with learning problems. The term "cognitive strategies" in
its simplest form is the use of the mind (cognition) to solve a problem or
complete a task. Cognitive strategies may also be referred to
as procedural facilitators (Bereiter & Scardamalia, 1987), procedural prompts (Rosenshine, 1997) or scaffolds (Palincsar
& Brown, 1984). The different cognitive strategies used in this work are;
Diagnostic strategies, Problem solving strategies, technical strategies, and
inter-personal strategies.
Engine Sound Diagnostic strategies refer to an individual's ability to identify a particular
problem and define it (Swamidass, 2000). These skills
are acquired through formal training, practice, and experimentation. When
a customer brings in their car for a repair, motor mechanics are often stressed
and overwhelmed. A great technician acknowledges this and is able to find the
source of the problem quickly and efficiently. Once they’ve diagnosed the
vehicle, they use their mechanical and electrical skills to complete the repair
and get the vehicle back up and running.
Mechanical
Problem-solving strategies
consists of using
generic methods and tools in an orderly manner to a solution to problems
(1989). As with any career, problems will
inevitably arise in the day-to-day work as a technician. This requires the
ability to problem-solve and think on one’s feet. Whether a repair is taking
longer than expected or a customer is unhappy with their vehicle, it’s the job
of a technician to come up with a solution that is best for the customer and
the company. As a motor
mechanic the goal is to figure out the problem and provide efficient and
effective service. The faster you can figure out the problem and give a
solution the faster your career growth will be. Every employer wants their
mechanic to be an independent problem solver. Without a problem-solving skill
you cannot be a great auto mechanic. The faster you can solve problems, the
faster you can reach the highest peak of your auto mechanic career. You will
get higher appreciation and higher customer satisfaction. It is true that, at
the beginning, you cannot detect problems so fast like an experienced one, but
your openness to solve problems will help you to learn faster than your peers. Auto technicians are knowledgeable about the wide variety of issues that
can occur in vehicles and how to solve them. Whether it’s a problem with the
brakes, electrical system or ignition, they are able to determine the issue,
execute the repair and communicate with the customer throughout the process.
Technical strategies are
the abilities and knowledge needed to perform
specific tasks. They are practical, and often relate to mechanical, information
technology, mathematical, or scientific tasks (Ferry, 2012). Medina
(2011) stated that technical skills are hard skills associated with the use of
tools, equipment related to work properly and efficiently, as well as all technical
matters. In the view of Abinu (cited in Agada, 2014) technical skills are the knowledge and
skills specific to a particular occupation or group of occupations. In this
study, technical skills refer to the ability to repair, service and maintain
engine components expertly and well in accordance to set standard or
manufacturer instructions. Giri (2015) stated that
mechanical technical skills expected in maintaining and servicing of carburetor include: cleaning and fixing to ensure float
chamber is clean to allows fuel through the jet into an enlarged carburetor passage, replace the defective pump, clean
properly the fuel lines and connecting unit and a new gasket should be used
while installing the pump at its place. Udogu (2015) stated
that the mechanical
technical skills that
are needed in maintaining and
servicing modern motor vehicle
ignition system includes, perform
magnetic sensor testing, use plug
wire or adapter to check for spark, test run the ignition system using the multimeter, check the crank sensor using diagnostic tool,
check the battery to make sure there is ample voltage to start the engine, test
and diagnose defective regulator sensor.
Interpersonal
strategies are
the behaviours and tactics a person uses to interact with others effectively (Gullick, 2015). In the business world, the term refers to
an employee's ability to work well with others. Interpersonal skills range from communication and listening
to attitude and deportment. According to Ferry (2013), interpersonal skills are
needed as a mechanic in the following categories; Dealing with customers. As a mechanic, one only has work
so long as one have customers will to bring their
vehicles for repairs and maintenance. So, if you want to be successful in your
career, you’re going to have to interact with customers frequently. Being able
to talk to customers with respect, empathy and understanding for their needs is
important. Also, they may encounter customers with complaints, or
unrealistic expectations, so they’ll need to be calm, measured and ready to
help them to the best of abilities with whatever concerns they have. At the end
of the day, one will want to build up enough of a rapport with customers to
keep them coming back for repairs, so it’s important that one keep things
positive and be transparent and professional with clients at all times.
Dealing with co-workers. Professionalism in your
demeanour extends not only to customers, but to colleagues as well. After
you become a mechanic, you’ll want to know when to
reach out for help from others and who to reach out to—to effectively
troubleshoot car issues in ways you may not already know. This is especially
important during your apprenticeship when you’ll be learning and making a
living at the same time. Likewise, your colleagues may reach out to you for
help or guidance as well, especially as you gain experience and newer hires
look to you for advice. Whether you’re looking for advice or giving it, having
the right communication skills can help.
Mechanic work is a trade
craftsmanship. Mechanic work involves
application of specific knowledge in the design, selection, construction,
operation and maintenance of automobiles. Mechanic work is a trade. Mechanic
work is geared to test, diagnose, service and completely maintain fault
relating to the conventional automobile assembly like vehicles of different
brands. Mechanic work enable workplace skills and create higher order thinking
skills which are needed in order to increase the learners’ flexibility and job
mobility which makes them adaptable to the present and envisaged changes (Hallak& Poison, 2000). The motor mechanic concepts used
in this study are; Panel biting/bodywork, electric works, general maintenance
and engine repairs.
Panel biting / bodywork. Automotive
repair shops that specialize in bodywork repair are known as body shops. They
offer paintwork repairs to scratches, scuffs and dents, as well as repairs to
the bodies of vehicles damaged by collisions (A traffic collision, also called a motor vehicle collision, car accident, or car crash, occurs when a vehicle collides with
another vehicle, pedestrian, animal, road debris, or other
stationary obstruction, such as a tree, pole or
building. Traffic collisions often result in injury, disability, death, and
property damage as well as financial costs to both society and the individuals
involved).
Electrical work means,
selection, assembling, constructing, installing, testing, fault-finding,
commissioning, maintaining, repairing, altering, removing, or replacing of
electrical equipment and/or electrical installations in a vehicle (Moss, 2019).
It may include the supervision or inspection of electrical work. In electrical
mechanics, the mechanic maintains, test, rebuild and repair electric motors, transformers,
switchgear and other electrical apparatus.
According to Marshell (2012), general maintenance means attendance to a fault that
requires maintenance or repair but is not of an immediate
safety concern to the public (for example loose fixing, objects obstructing
access to normal maintenance of
equipment). To Marsehell (2012), the duties of
general maintenance are; inspects and identifies equipment or machines in need
of repair. Troubleshoots issues to determine necessary repairs.
Plans repair work
using buildings blueprints or equipment manual as needed. Performs general repairs that do not
require a specialized technician.
Engine repairs is the process of routinely
checking the various systems and components that compose a car engine, and
performing any repairs or upgrades that are necessary to keep the engine in
proper running condition (Tatum, 2021). The typical car owner performs a few
basic maintenance tasks on his or her own, while relying on a mechanic to
manage the remainder of those tasks. A solid automobile repair schedule can
increase gas mileage while also adding years of service to the engine.
Contextually, the use of cognitive strategies can increase the
efficiency with which the learner approaches a learning task. These academic
tasks can include, but are not limited to, remembering and applying information
from course content, constructing sentences and paragraphs, editing written
work, paraphrasing, and classifying cognitive strategies to be learned in a
motor mechanic workshop. In a classroom where cognitive strategies are used, the
teacher fulfils a pivotal role, bridging the gap between student and
content/skill to be learned. This role requires an understanding of the task to
be completed, as well as knowledge of an approach (or approaches) to the task
that he/she can communicate to the learner.
Cognitive strategies therefore are instructional approaches that helps
teach complex skills and reasoning, through authentic task. In designing a
cognitive strategy environment, the expert might ask; what are the central
skills and concepts of the subject area one will want to master and how can one
make thinking visible. Cognitive strategy focuses on the development of
learners and skills beyond the apprehension of subject matter content (For
example, troubleshooting procedures and applications of diagnostic skills used
in workplace). In cognitive strategy, the challenge is to present a range of
task varying from systematic and diverse to encourage learners to reflect on
and articulate the elements that are common across task. The goal of cognitive
strategy is to help learners generalize the skills, to learn when the skill is
or not applicable, and to transfer the skill independently when faced with
novel situation (Lave, 1988).
Motor mechanics venture is becoming a very lucrative one in the 21st
century, due to the fact that almost everyone at this age owns a car and needs
maintenance from time-to-time. There is therefore a need to apply cognitive
strategies as a way of acquiring these motor mechanic skills. Some cognitive
strategies applied in the motor mechanic venture are; talking to customers about their vehicle’s problems finding and
diagnosing faults using hand tools or a computer, advising customers on what
repairs are needed, estimating time and costs for jobs, repairing and replacing
faulty parts, road testing vehicles to check repairs, carrying out scheduled
servicing and maintenance, fitting accessories like stereos and alarms,
checking stock levels and parts, updating vehicle service records(Outsen & Yulga, 2002).
The lecture method is being used predominantly in teaching mechanic or
automobile technology and it is based on behavioural learning theories (Boyle,
2003). Emphasis is placed on transmission from the expert to the passive
novice. Therefore, the increase effect of globalization and the rapid
technological changes in the workplace have been acknowledge in the
recommendation by UNESCO (2002) which states that technical education should be
geared towards lifelong learning. This entails that workplace skills such as
creativity, problem solving, collaborative skills should be encouraged.
Mechanic work comprised of the following components; calibrating brakes, car
engine, screws in tightening parts, electrical system in vehicles, combustion
and diesel mot.
Theoretical Anchors on the study
Theoretically, this paper was anchored on the following learning
theories; Atkinson and Shriffrin’s information
processing theory, (1968) Lev Vygotsky’s socio-cultural theory (1934), John Flavel’s metacognition theory (1978) and Albert Bandura’s
Observational learning theory (1963).
Information processing is the change (processing) of information in any
manner detectable by an observer. As such, it is a process that describes that,
everything that happens change in the universe, from
the falling of a rock (a change in positive) to the printing of a text from a
digital computer system. In the latter case, an information processor is
changing the form of presentation of that file. Information processing may more
specifically be defined in terms used by Claude E. Shannon as the conversion of
latent information into manifest information (MC Gongnigle
& Masddrien, 2011). Latent and manifest
information is defined through the terms of equivocation, remaining
uncertainty, what value the sender has actually chosen. The theory describes
how knowledge from the environment gets to the sensory register, the moves the short-term
memory via semantic encoding and finally gets to the long term memory through
repetition, rehearsal, elaboration and practice. The information accumulated by
apprentices in motor mechanic garages is learnt via information processing.
Metacognitive theory by John Flavell (1978). Research activity in metacognition began with John Flavell who is
considered to be the father of the field. Metacognition is a concept that has
been refers to a variety of epistemological processes. Metacognition
essentially means cognition about cognition; that thoughts about thoughts,
knowledge about knowledge. So, if metacognition involves perceiving remembering
and so forth, then metacognition involves thinking about one’s own perceiving,
understanding, remembering. These various cognitions about cognition can be
labelled “metacognition”, “meta comprehension” and “meta memory” with
metacognition remaining the superordinate term. Flavell (1978) referred to
metacognition a knowledge that takes as it objects or regulates any aspects of
any cognitive endeavours. Metacognition is defined in simplest terms as
thinking about your own thinking. The root “meta” means “beyond”, so the term
refers to “beyond thinking”. Specifically, this means it encompasses the
processes of planning, tracking and assessing your own understanding or
performance.
Vygotsky believed that individual development could not be understood
without reference to the social and cultural context within which such
development is embedded. He states that using activity mediators, the human
being is able to modify the environment and this is her way of interacting with
nature. Hence, Zone of Proximal Development is actually the gap between actual
competence level (what problem level a learner is able to independently solve),
and the potential development level (what problem level could she solve with
guidance from a tutor). It supports a representation of intellectual
development based on continuity. It states that learning can force cognitive
development. It states the role of the expert as a necessary mediator of
novices’ cognitive development.
Therefore, the Zone of Proximal Development is based the mental
functions that have not yet matured but are being in the process of maturation.
It supports a representation of intellectual development based on continuity.
It states that learning can force cognitive development, and with scaffolding,
cognitive development in the zones of proximal development stresses the role of
a social partner of the novice (An expert or a more skilled peer). Also, with
scaffolding, the instructor becomes supportive tool for the student in the zone
of proximal development. The characteristics of an ideal teacher are those in
which scaffolding provides support, it functions as a tool, it allows to
accomplish a task otherwise impossible. In Vygotsky’s view, learning is an
interactive interpersonal activity. The psychological mechanism is to create
(external) activities that will be later internalized by novice. Relating this
theory to the study, the patrons are seen as the teachers who are the authority
of motor mechanic knowledge, they pass through the
process of scaffolding to provide guidance to the apprentice so that they reach
the zone of proximal development.
Observational
learning is a method of learning that consists of observing and modeling another individual’s behaviour, attitudes, or
emotional expressions. Although it is commonly believed that the observer will
copy the model. Albert Bandura stressed that individuals may simply learn from the behaviour rather
than imitate it. Observational learning is a major component of Bandura’s social learning theory. He also emphasized that four conditions were necessary in any
form of observing and modelling behaviour: attention, retention, reproduction,
and motivation. In the learning of motor mechanics via cognitive strategies,
the learners (apprentices) must observe the teacher (patron) in assimilating a skill
(Kouzekanani, 2000).
Diagnostic strategies and acquisition of motor mechanic skills
Ziblim, Nkrummah and Imoro (2012) carried out a study on “Assessing the Skills of Roadside Mechanics in Diagnosing and Fixing
Problems of Modern Electronic Managed Vehicles in Ghana (Tamale Metropolis)”.
The study sampled 35 mechanic workshops around the district consisting of 120
motor mechanics. In the study, the various vehicle repair and maintenance
skills used by roadside mechanics were investigated using questionnaires as
data collection tool. The study revealed that, a large number of the
auto-mechanics in the Tamale Metropolis have considerable years of auto repair
working experience, but lack the ability to inspect and repair modern
electronic managed vehicles due to low educational and technical levels. The
study also indicates that, the auto mechanics lack the ability to use modern
diagnostic equipment, manufacturer’s manuals, computers and internet which have
characterized modern vehicle repairs, in their repair practices. It is
recommended that, government should assist in training roadside mechanics to
upgrade their knowledge and skills in the area of automotive electronics.
Training institutions and organizations such as the universities, polytechnics,
National Board for Small Scale Industries (NBSSI), etc., should assist
particularly in the form of education and training to equip roadside mechanics
with the requisite skills and technology to be able to work on the electronic
managed vehicles.
Ezeama, Obe and Ede
(2016) conducted a study on “Assessment of Diagnostic skills among Motor
Vehicle Mechanics Trainers for the use of auto scan tools”. This study examined
the diagnostic needs among motor vehicle mechanics trainers in the use of auto
scan tools. Three research questions and three null hypotheses guided the
study. The study was carried out in three institutions where motor vehicle
mechanics trade is offered as automobile technology or automobile education,
three centres where auto scan tools are used for vehicle repairs and two
technical colleges in Enugu state that offer motor vehicle mechanics (MVM)
trade. The population of the study consisted of eighty-three (83) MVM trainers,
teachers and instructors. The instrument which was structured on two types of
response scale (perceived importance and expressed performance) to elicit
information on the use of auto scan tool for diagnosing some vehicle systems
faults. Data collected were analysed using the mean and the improvement needed
index (INI) to answer the research questions.
Then t- test statistic was used to test the
null hypotheses at 0.05% level of significance. The study found out that MVM
trainers need capacity building in the use of auto scan tools for vehicle
systems diagnosis and repairs. The study recommended that workshop/seminars
should be organized by centres like the National center
for equipment maintenance and development, the National automotive council and
so on to enable MVM trainers acquire the required skills to meet up with the
training job facing them.
Problem solving strategies and the
acquisition of motor mechanic skills
Behrman, Stadt and Mc
Daniels (1996) carried out a study of on “effective problem solving
instructional method in College Automobile classrooms”. The purpose of the
study was to determine whether problem solving instruction method represents an
improved method for helping automotive students learn information and diagnose
problems. Three research questions were posed to examine the difference between
the two instructional methods. A quasi-experimental design was used to compare
problem solving that us cognitive strategies instructional design was used with
the traditional lecture method. A sample consisted of 28 students in two automotive classes of the college
of Technical Career with age ranging 19 to 49 years. Although groups had a
mixture of group levels, the experimental group was composed of more seniors.
The students in the control group have four
years prior to the study. The experimental treatment group consisted of
a series of laboratory design to be consistent with the cognitive
apprenticeship characteristics described below.
The control group
received the same content primarily through presentations of theory in a
lecture setting followed by the methods of coaching where experts assist
students by giving hints and support with fading where expert gradually remove
support until the students are on their own. The instrument was a
multiple-choice test containing a total of 25 questions sub divided in to three
areas. a) Air conditioning information, b) troubleshooting
procedures and c) application of diagnostic skills. Content validity for
data collection instrument was enhanced by using Automatize Service Excellence
Certification preparation test as a guide for developing the 25 questions. 2 colleges automotive air conditioning professors assisted in
the construction of the instrument. This was done to ensure content validity (Cronbaeh Alpha) were computed for
each subscale of the questionnaire. A repeated measure ANOVA was used to test
the differences between the effects (Experimental versus control groups). A
t-test was used to examine pre-treatment difference. When compared with the
traditional lecture-based test, control group methodology, the problem solving
treatment results were significantly more effective for the acquisition of air
conditioning information, knowledge of trouble shooting procedures and
application of diagnostic skills.
Technical strategies and the acquisition of
motor mechanic skills
Okwelle and Tombari
(2017) carried out a study on “Technical Skills Needed by Motor Vehicle
Mechanic Apprentice to Establish Standard Motor Mechanic Enterprise in Port
Harcourt Metropolis, Rivers State”. The study investigated mechanical technical
skills required by apprentice of motor vehicle mechanic (MVM) to qualify for
graduation as MVM artisan and establish standard motor mechanic enterprise in
Port Harcourt metropolis. The study adopted the descriptive survey research
design. The sample of the study comprised 63 MVM artisans operating in MVM
workshops in Ikoku Mechanic village Diobu, Port Harcourt, who were purposively sampled. The
instrument used for data collection was a structured questionnaire which was
faced validated by three experts. The reliability of the instrument was
established by using Cronbach Alpha reliability method to obtain the
reliability coefficient was 0.86. Three research questions guided the study.
Mean and standard deviation were used to answer the research questions. The
study revealed modern technical skills in maintenance of ignition systems, carburetors as well as wheel alignment and balancing
required by MVMW apprentice to qualify for graduation as MVM artisan and
establish standard Motor Vehicle Mechanic enterprise in Port Harcourt
metropolis. Based on the findings, recommendation was made among which
included: Government should establish modern motor vehicle mechanic workshops
that would train apprentice of MVM on technical skills required in maintaining
and repairing of fuel system, ignition system and wheel alignment and balancing
of motor vehicles wheels and tyres. The industries and motor vehicle companies
should establish more service centres in Port Harcourt metropolis to train
interested youths at subsidized rate.
Another study was carried out by Olaita and Ikeh (2015) on “Employability and Technical Skill Required to Establish a Small-Scale
Automobile Workshop”. The study focused on identifying the employability and
technical skills needed to establish small-scale automobile workshop in Nsukka
Urban of Enugu State. Five purposes of the study were stated to guide the
study. Five research questions were stated and answered in line with the
purpose of the study. The population for the study is 1,500 registered
automobile mechanics in the study area. Simple random sampling technique was
employed to select 150 automobile mechanics and was used for the study. The
instrument for data collection was a questionnaire developed from literature
review. The Questionnaire was administered on 150 automobile mechanics in the
Nsukka Mechanic Village, and was retrieved and analysed using frequency
distribution, percentage and mean. The study revealed among others that to
establish and to progress in automobile business, employability skills,
technical skills, managerial skills, basic tools, equipment and facilities as
well as finance are of great importance to the prospecting auto mechanic.
Recommendations were given based on the findings from the study.
Interpersonal strategies and the
acquisition of motor mechanic skills
Dotsey (2011) carried out a study on “The
influence of staff training on customer service” The research was conducted base on the following
objectives among others. To identify the various training models used by
management of Private Companies to train its staff, to assess the influence of
training in employee’s quality service delivery and to assess management
orientation and commitment to staff training. The study was conducted with a
sample size of five hundred (500). These consist of two hundred (200) workers and three hundred
(300) customers. This was practicable since it was not possible to sample the
entire workforce under discussion. With the aid of the methodology used, the
research was successful in arriving at the following findings; It was discovered from the study that most Private company’s
organizes periodic job training programs which last for a period of one week
for its staff, and are internally supervised. It was also discovered that
perception about Private company’s product is at a
high rate; their services are portrayed as quality as compared to other
services and that customer’s leave the company happy after being attended to.
It
can be concluded that customer’s complaints are handled professionally after
the training program. It was also discovered that Private company’s workers are
motivated to go on training and that all staff are not actually included in the
training programs organized in the organization. It is also clear that the
services can be improved to the benefit of customers in achieving the
organization objectives. The researchers also recommend among others the
following; Management of Private Companies Limited should increase the training
duration and the content of the training should be at least two weeks and above
for effectiveness. All the departments and all individuals in the department
should be involved in the training session. In other for customers to perceive
the services rendered by Private companies very high, workers of the company
must do well to follow up with customers’ grievances to satisfy their requirement
thus post purchase since this well defines the essence of customer service. It
is an undeniable fact that training employees will have positive impact on
their performance. This would ultimately lead to quality service delivery and
to achieving objectives of the organization
Statement of the
problem
The acquisition of motor mechanic skills is very primordial in the life
of any apprentice mechanic, it is expected that apprentices after going through
training from the trainers will be masters in the motor mechanic profession and
even open up their own workshops, but from observation and experience from many
mechanic workshops, these apprentices are unable to generate the appropriate
strategies and skills that will make them self-reliant and open up their own
mechanic workshops. Some who succeed in opening their own workshop are still
unable to fix and solve common and complex motor mechanic matters and issues,
reducing and tarnishing the image of motor mechanics. Nevertheless, some of
these learners because of the complex nature of the motor mechanic task, tend to drop out from the trade/profession. It was for
this reason therefore the researcher decided to find out how cognitive
strategies can enhance the acquisition of motor mechanic skills in some mechanic
shops in Buea Municipality.
Ha1: There exist a relationship between cognitive strategies and the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency
H01: There is no relationship between cognitive strategies and the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency.
Ha2: There exist a relationship between problem solving strategies and the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency
H02: There is no relationship between problem solving strategies and the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency.
Ha3: There exist a relationship between technical skills and the acquisition
of motor mechanic competency.
H03: There is no relationship between technical skills and the acquisition of
motor mechanic competency.
Ha4: There exist a relationship between inter-personal relationship and the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency.
H04: There is no relationship between inter-personal relationship and the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency.
METHODS
The study employed a concurrent triangulation
nested design. The theoretical perspective is dominantly qualitative.
Concurrent triangulation is characterized by the fact that two or more methods are used to confirm,
cross-validate, or corroborate findings within a study; data collection is
concurrent. The purpose is substantiated by the fact that generally, both
methods are used to overcome a weakness in using one method with the strength
of another as to clarify unexpected findings and/or potential contradictions;
for instance, combining a survey questionnaire with interview (Creswell, 2000;
Nana, 2018). But in this the context of this study, questionnaire and interview
will be used to investigate how cognitive strategies facilitate the acquisition
of motor mechanic skills.
The population was made up of all apprentices and trainers (patrons)
involved in mechanic work in Buea Municipality in the
non-formal sector. The Regional Delegation for Employment and Vocational
Training had no statistics on the number of trainers and apprentices in
mechanic work in Buea Municipality. The target
population of this study comprised of sixty (60) apprentices in Buea Municipality engaged in mechanic work. While the accessible population was made up of twelve (30)
apprentices in mechanic garages and 10 trainers.
A sample of 60 apprentices and 10 trainers were selected for the study.
The study was done in five garages. The first garage called C.O.I.C garage 16 apprentices
2 trainer. Second garages “Kilonomic garage” located
at mile 17 with 13 apprentices. While garage three called
“Top ten” located at Molyko with 7 apprentices.
Garage four known as “Fako Garage” located at Bonduma, with 15 apprentices and Garage five known as
“Faith Auto garage” located at Bokwai junction with 9
apprentices. This sample is justified by Goldstein & Pollock (1989) who
states that in obtaining best results in any skill training programme, a group
of three (3) to six (6) learners is appropriate. Accordingly, small groups
enable novices to socially interact and share ideas and give feedback. All the
garages had two trainers each.
|
S/N |
Name of garage |
No. of Apprentices |
No. Of Trainers |
|
1. |
O.I.C Garage |
16 |
2 |
|
2. |
Kilonomic Garage, Mile17 |
13 |
2 |
|
3. |
Top ten, Molyko |
7 |
2 |
|
4. |
Fako garage, Bonduma |
15 |
2 |
|
5. |
Faith Auto Garage, Bokwai
Junction |
9 |
2 |
|
|
Total |
60 |
10 |
The sampling technique used in this study was convenient sampling
technique. Convenient sampling is a type of non-probability
sampling that involves the sample being drawn from that part of the population
that is close to hand. The researcher used this sampling technique to select
those garages that are close at hand and are accessible around the Buea Municipality. This sampling technique was seen
appropriate for this work as it will save the researcher time to be moving all
around garages in the Buea Municipality, he will just
select the ones that are accessible and easy to reach.
The instruments used for the collection of data were a questionnaire and
interview schedule. While the questionnaire was used to collect data from the
apprentices, the interview guide was used to collect data from trainers
(patrons).
FINDINGS
|
Statement |
SA |
A |
D |
SD |
|
I am able to detect
car faults when they come for repairs |
01 (4%) |
22 (88%) |
02 (8%) |
00 (0%) |
|
The ability to
detect car faults makes me learn motor mechanics effectively |
07 (28%) |
17 (68%) |
01 (4%) |
00 (0%) |
|
Identifying oil
leakages improves my learning of motor mechanics |
03 (12%) |
21 (84%) |
01 (4%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can pinpoint car
faults at first sight when it comes to the garage for repairs |
03 (12%) |
08 (32%) |
14 (56%) |
00 (0%) |
|
We are being
trained on identifying faulty brake systems |
03 (12%) |
17 (68%) |
05 (20%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can identify
unwanted noise from car engines |
03 (12%) |
14 (56%) |
08 (32%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can detect the
pulling fault of a car |
04 (16%) |
16 (64%) |
03 (12%) |
02 (8%) |
|
Recognizing car
faults cannot facilitate learning of motor mechanics |
02 (8%) |
06 (24%) |
05 (20%) |
12 (48%) |
|
MRS |
|
|
|
|
From table 2 above many
respondents 88% can detect
car faults when they come for repairs, 68% indicated that the ability to detect
car faults makes them to learn motor mechanics effectively, 84% said
identifying oil leakages improves their learning of motor mechanics, 56%
indicated that they are able to pinpoint
car faults at first sight when it comes to the garage for repairs, 68%
acknowledged being trained on identifying faulty brake systems, 56% agreed they
can identify noise from car engines, 64% agreed they can detect the pulling
fault of a car and 48% strongly disagreed that recognizing car faults cannot
facilitate learning of motor mechanics.
|
Correlations |
|||
|
|
Diagnostic
strategy |
acquisition
of motor mechanic skills |
|
|
Diagnostic strategy |
Pearson Correlation |
1 |
.435* |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
|
.030 |
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
|
acquisition of motor mechanic skills |
Pearson Correlation |
.435* |
1 |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
.030 |
|
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
|
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05
level (2-tailed). |
|||
A pearson product
moment correlation was run to determine the relationship between the diagnostic
strategy and the learning of motor mechanics. There was a moderate positive
correlation between problem solving strategy and the learning of motor
mechanics at (r=0,435, n=25, p=0,030). There was statistically enough evidence (r =
0.435, p=0.020, p<0.05) that diagnostic strategies positively and
significantly influence on the acquisition of motor mechanic competencies.
|
Statement |
SA |
A |
D |
SD |
|
I use problem
solving strategy to solve the problem of brake failure |
06 (24%) |
19 (76%) |
00 (0%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can solve problem
of oil shortage in the engine |
09 (36%) |
11 (44%) |
05 (20%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can identify and
solve short-circuit problems in a car |
04 (16%) |
13 (52%) |
08 (32%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can solve the
fault of hard-starting |
07 (28%) |
12 (48%) |
06 (24%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can identify and
solve faulty earth connection |
03 (12%) |
13 (52%) |
09 (36%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I solve most car
faults after diagnosing them |
03 (12%) |
17 (68%) |
05 (20%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can do car engine
timing |
06 (24%) |
10 (40%) |
06 (24%) |
03 (12%) |
|
Problem solving skills
has no effect on the acquisition of motor mechanics skills |
05 (20%) |
12 (48%) |
04 (16%) |
04 (16%) |
From table 3 above most respondents agreed as follows: 76% they used
problem
solving strategy to solve the problem of brake failure, 44% they can solve problem
of oil shortage in the engine, 52% can identify and solve short-circuit
problems in a car, 48% can solve the fault of hard-starting, 52% can identify
and solve faulty earth connection, 68% agreed solve most car faults after
diagnosing them, 40% agreed they can do car engine timing and 48% agreed that
problem solving skills has no effect on the acquisition of motor mechanics
skills.
|
Correlations |
|||
|
|
Problem
solving strategy |
The
learning of motor mechanics |
|
|
Problem solving strategy |
Pearson Correlation |
1 |
.343 |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
|
.093 |
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
|
The learning of motor mechanics |
Pearson Correlation |
.343 |
1 |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
.093 |
|
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
A Pearson product moment correlation was run to determine the
relationship between the problem-solving strategy and the learning of motor
mechanics. There was a moderate positive correlation between problem solving
strategy and the learning of motor mechanics was statistically insignificant
(r=0,343, n=25, p=0,093). There was statistically enough evidence (r = 0.343,
p=0.093) that problem solving strategies positively but insignificantly
influences on the acquisition of motor mechanic competencies.
|
Statement |
SA |
A |
D |
SD |
|
I can panel bit the
bonnet of a vehicle |
08 (32%) |
13 (52%) |
04 (16%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can set the door
inches of a vehicle |
12 (48%) |
09 (36%) |
02 (8%) |
02 (8%) |
|
I can fix a short
circuit problem |
09 (36%) |
16 (64%) |
00 (0%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can drain oil
from the engine through the draining plug |
10 (40%) |
13 (52%) |
02 (8%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can service the
brake master cylinder |
08 (32%) |
13 (52%) |
04 (16%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I can clean air
filter elements |
08 (32%) |
13 (52%) |
02 (8%) |
02 (8%) |
|
I can dismount and
mount the exhaust manifold |
10 (40%) |
11 (44%) |
02 (8%) |
02 (8%) |
|
Technical skills
cannot help me to learn motor mechanics |
10 (40%) |
12 (48%) |
05 (20%) |
07 (28%) |
From table 4 above most
respondents 48% strongly agreed that they can set the door inches for a
vehicle. Also,
many of the respondents agreed as follows, 52% they can panel bit the bonnet of
a vehicle, 64% can fix a short circuit problem, 52% can service the brake master cylinder,
drain oil from the engine through the draining plug, and can clean air filter
elements, whilst 44% can dismount and mount the exhaust manifold as well as 48%
agreed technical skills could not help them to learn motor mechanics.
|
Correlations |
|||
|
|
Technical
strategy |
the
acquisition of motor mechanics |
|
|
Technical strategy |
Pearson Correlation |
1 |
.550** |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
|
.004 |
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
|
the acquisition of motor mechanics |
Pearson Correlation |
.550** |
1 |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
.004 |
|
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
|
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01
level (2-tailed). |
|||
A Pearson product moment
correlation was run to determine the relationship between the technical strategy and the learning of motor mechanics.
There was a moderate positive correlation between problem solving strategy and
the learning of motor mechanics was statistically significant (r=0,550, n=25,
p=0,004). There
was statistically enough evidence (r = 0.550, p=0.004, p<0.05) that
technical strategies positively and significantly influence on the acquisition
of motor mechanic competencies.
|
Statement |
SA |
A |
D |
SD |
|
I relate well with
my co-apprentices |
10 (40%) |
15 (60%) |
00 (0%) |
00 (0%) |
|
We work together in
doing mechanic works, helping each other in doing tasks. |
15 (60%) |
10 (40%) |
00 (0%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I am able to
negotiate and communicate well with clients |
02 (8%) |
23 (92%) |
00 (0%) |
00 (0%) |
|
Good interpersonal
relationship with clients will make them bring more clients to the garage |
15 (60%) |
05 (20%) |
05 (20%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I enjoy working
with clients. |
14 (56%) |
09 (36%) |
02 (8%) |
00 (0%) |
|
I communicate well
with clients coming to the garage |
03 (12%) |
21 (84%) |
00 (0%) |
01 (4%) |
|
I usually get angry
with some clients who put me pressure in fixing their cars |
09 (36%) |
08 (32%) |
05 (20%) |
03 (12%) |
|
The ability to
relate and interact with my fellow apprentices and clients facilitates my
acquisition of motor mechanic skills |
10 (40%) |
13 (52%) |
02 (8%) |
00 (0%) |
From table 5 above most
respondents strongly agreed 60% that they work together in doing mechanic works,
helping each other in doing tasks, 60% that good interpersonal relationship
with clients will make them bring more clients to the garage, 56% that they
enjoyed working with clients, and 36% that usually get angry with some clients
who put me pressure in fixing their cars. Also, many apprentices agreed that
relate well with my co-apprentices, 92% that they are able to negotiate and
communicate well with clients, 84% that they communicate well with clients
coming to the garage, and 52% indicated that their ability to relate and
interact with their fellow apprentices and clients facilitates their
acquisition of motor mechanic skills.
|
Correlations |
|||
|
|
interpersonal |
acquisition4 |
|
|
interpersonal |
Pearson Correlation |
1 |
.380 |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
|
.061 |
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
|
acquisition4 |
Pearson Correlation |
.380 |
1 |
|
Sig. (2-tailed) |
.061 |
|
|
|
N |
25 |
25 |
|
A Pearson product moment correlation was run to determine the
relationship between the interpersonal strategy and the learning of motor mechanics. There was a positive
correlation between problem solving strategy and the learning of motor
mechanics was statistically insignificant (r=0,380, n=25, p=0,061). There was
statistically enough evidence (r = 0.343, p=0.061) that interpersonal
strategies positively but insignificantly influence on the acquisition of motor
mechanic competencies.
What
are the
different diagnostic strategies you use in diagnosing car faults?
There were diverse diagnostic strategies advanced by trainers in motor mechanic
workshops. Most of the strategies through experience were indicated as follows: “I use my knowledge
and personal skills due to long time experience
in this field”, “with my long time experiences, I diagnose some faults by listening to the sound and smoke produced by the engine
of the car”. Again, “les anciens payne au register et resolve ne permete de presourdre les nouveaux pagne
ocasione”. Other diagnostic
strategies included the used of digital
diagnostic tools for auto-detect, as well, many diagnostic problems beyond
the technician’s ability
are further discussed in the over social
media; “we have some other diagnostic skills by discussing or a group
call mechanic world forum over whatsapp”.
Diagnostic strategies
have been seen to assist trainers in various ways. To many, it helps to solve both simple
and complex problems
in garages. As most of the trainers
opined that “je utilize mon talent et mon experience en
mechanic”, “as long as one does
something every day he must understand it because they say practice makes perfect”, implying that knowledge
gained from diagnostic strategies is a guide for future problem-solving tasks in the garage. Apart from this, some trainers
it guarantees quality work and
establishes good social relations as reported “It helps me to do work
effectively and to maximise time to do the work and
helps to keep good relations with customers”.
The problem-solving
strategies here included observations and critical thinking. To be able to solve problems identified, a
mechanic must observe keenly the situation at
hand, and think out of the box. There are also diagnostic machines that are
being used in solving problems
from car faults.
Others listen to the sound
of the car engine from à distance
; “je ecoute le
son du noteur ou je conduit le vehicules pour
une distance”.
The different problem-solving
strategies are very essential in motor mechanics. To most trainer, “It helps in
such a way that one can spend less time in doing his work since
he is already use to the cars happening problems”. “it helps to solve common and complex faults in the garage”.
What are the different technical strategies you use in
solving car faults?
Trainers employ different technical
strategies in solving car problems.
“Sometimes I Google just to learn more”.
“I sometimes ask my
friends in the field
when I do not understand”. To
some, it is an issue of critical thinking and the use of human sense of hearing, touch and smell. Technical skills
generally facilitate their learning of motor mechanics by giving them practical
skills
Motor mechanic
trainers adopt different interpersonal strategies when dealing with clients
and apprentices. For the apprentices most of them indicate that they take time to listen keenly
to their difficulties, in order to tell them to solve their problem.
They therefore create
time to listen
to the apprentice before
taking any action with them.
Trainers indicated
that interpersonal skills with clients
are of paramount importance. This
importance could be of three categories: diagnosing, problem- solving, maintenance and economic
purposes. Upon arrival at the workshop, the
client needs to be listened to
carefully so as to ease diagnosis processes. They explained as follows;
“I listen carefully to my clients and advise them on what should be done to the car-fault”, “To the client
I listen very well to their problems
and tell them what to do to get their car running”, “Since I deal with many people a day, these skills help me to interact
with different faces and make job easier” and
“My interpersonal skills help me to do
costumer work quick and faster and it
also helps me to bring more customers to my work place”
Thus, good personal skill
gives each trainer
the upper hands to good relationship with all kinds of
people and it also helps to bring others to the workplace/garage with respect
to the quality of services
too. Hear them “…interpersonal skills help my interaction with clients in given them the
appropriate fault they are serving with their cars and solving their issues on their cars in time, and bring more
customers to the work place, leading to much income earnings”.
The main aim of the study was to find out the
effect of cognitive strategies on the acquisition of motor mechanic competency
within Buea Municipality. The specific research objectives
were to find out the influence of diagnostic skills on the
acquisition of motor mechanic competency, to find out the influence of Problem
skills on the acquisition of motor mechanic competency, to find out the
influence of technical solving skills on the acquisition of motor mechanic
competency, and to determine the influence of inter-personal skills on the acquisition
of motor mechanic competency. Considering the findings of this study, it can be
concluded that, diagnostic strategies positively and significantly influences
the acquisition of motor mechanic competency, problem strategies positively but
insignificantly influences the acquisition of motor mechanic competency,
technical solving strategies positively and significantly influences
acquisition of motor mechanic competency and inter-personal strategies
positively and insignificantly influences the acquisition of motor mechanic
competency.
Based on the findings
of the study the researcher recommends the following;
·
Government
should assist in training roadside mechanics to upgrade their knowledge and
skills in the area of automotive electronics.
·
Training
institutions and organizations such as the universities, polytechnics, Board
for Small Scale Industries etc., should assist particularly in the form of
education and training to equip roadside mechanics with the requisite skills
and technology to be able to work on the electronic managed vehicles.
·
Government should establish modern motor vehicle mechanic
workshops that would train apprentice of Motor vehicle mechanics on technical
skills required in maintaining and repairing of fuel system, ignition system
and wheel alignment and balancing of motor vehicles wheels and tyres.
·
Trainers or patrons should be sensitized on maintaining and
sustaining good interpersonal relationships with their apprentices.
·
Also,
apprentices should as well be sensitized on maintaining and sustaining good
interpersonal relationships with customers.
REFERENCES
Agebure, A. B. (2014). An Investigation into the Management of Vehicle Repair Garagesin the Bolgatanga
Municipality of Ghana. European Journal of Business and Management.vol.6(32);25-49
Baker, D. and
Brown, K (1984). Beyond communities
of practice: language, power, and social context. Cambridge
University Press.
Barry, C.M.
& Nelson, L.J., (2005).The role of religion in the transition to adulthood
for young emerging adults. European Journal of Psychological Research, 3 (2): 2057-4794
Camp,
W. G. (1983). Social efficiency and vocational education: An examination of our
changing philosophies. Journal of Vocational Education Research 8(3), 10-19.
Ceci, S. J. and Ruiz, A. I. (1993). Inserting context into our thinking about thinking:
Implications fora theory of everyday intelligent behavior.
In M. Rabinowitz (Ed.), Cognitive science foundations of instruction (pp.
173-188), Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Chaiklen, S. and Lave, J. (Eds) (1993). Understanding Practice.
UK: Cambridge University Press.
Chapman, M.
(1988). Constructive
evolution: Origins and development of Piaget’s thought. New York: Cambridge
University Press.
Chee, Y. S.,
Tan, J. T. and Chan, T. (1993). Situated sense-making: A study of conceptual change in activity-based
learning. In Proceedings of the Fifteenth Annual Conference of the Cognitive
Science Society, Boulder, CO. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Fishbach, R. M. (1993). Teaching problems-solving and
technical mathematics through cognitive apprenticeship at community college
level. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No.
ED 352455)
Flavell, J. H. (1971). First
discussant's comments: What is memory development the development of? Human
Development, 14: 272-278.
Flavell, J. H. (1976). Metacognitive aspects of problem solving, In L. B. Resnick (Ed),
The Nature of Intelligence 231-235. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Flavell, J. H. (1977). Cognitive development. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
Publishing.
Flavell, J. H. (1978). Metacognitive development. In J. M. Scandura
& C. J. Brainerd (Eds.), Structural/process theories of complex human behavior ,
213-245. Alphen aan den Rijn, the Netherlands: Sijthoff and Noordhoff.
Flavell, J. H. (1979).
Metacognition and cognitive monitoring: A new area of cognitive development
enquiry. American Psychologist, 34: 906-911.
Fluitman,
F., Birks, S. Oudin, X., & Sinclair, C. (1994). Skills acquisition
in micro-enterprises: Evidence from West Africa. Paris: Organization for
Economic Cooperation and Development.
Funkhouser,
J. (2013). How innovation has changed the job of auto repair technician. Washington Post.
Gallimore, R.,
& Tharp, R. (1990). Teaching mind in society: Teaching, schooling, and literate discourse.
In L. C. Moll (Ed.), Vygotsky and education: Instructional implications and
applications of socio-historical psychology. New York: Cambridge.
Jalal,
D. (2013). enhance capacity building in line with the
approved National Automotive Industry
Jeffrey,
N. R. (2015). 40-millionth Toyota Corolla ever built. Autoblog.com. Retrieved
2015-02-17.
Kayemuddin,
M., & Kayum, S. (2013).Problems and prospects of
automobile workshops in Bangladesh. Journal of African
Studies and Development, 5(6), 157.
Kinyanjui
M. N. (2000). Tapping opportunities in jua
kali enterprises clusters: The case of Ziwani and Kigandain. Nairob. European Centre for Research Training
and Development UK.
Kuhn, D. &
Dean, D. (2004). A
bridge between cognitive psychology and educational practice. Theory
into Practice, 43(4): 268-273.
Kuhn, D. (2000). Metacognitive development. Current Directions in
Psychological Science, 9(5), 178-181.
Lave, J. (1988). The culture of acquisition and the practice of understanding.
(Report No. IRL88-0007). Palo-Alto, CA: Institute for
Research on Learning.
Lave, J. (1993). The Practice of Learning. In Chaiklen,
S. and Lave, J (Eds). Understanding Practice. UK:
Cambridge University Press.
Lave, J. (1996) Teaching, as
learning, in practice. Mind, Culture and Society, 3 (3).
Lave, J. and Wenger, E. (1991). Situated Learning.
UK: Cambridge Press.
Lawrence, J.
A. and Valsiner, J. (1993). Conceptual roots of internalization: From transmission to
transformation. Human Development, 36: 150–167.
Lindsay,
C. (2013). How car will get more helpful. Available on: www.autocar.com. Retrieved fromwww.autorcar.com.
Oakes, J.,
& Lipton, M. (1999). Teaching to change the world. Boston:
McGraw-Hill College.
Okogba, F.I. (1991). Vocational education and the informal system. Nigerian
Vocational Journal,2( 4)1–6.
Olson (Ed.), The
social foundations of language and thought. New York: Norton
Oni,
C. S. (2006). Vocationalism in Nigerian Education. Journal
of Social Science, 12(2): 147-150.
Orr, J. (1991) Narrative at Work,
in Middleton, D. and Engestrom Y. (Eds). Collective Remembering. UK: Sage.
Otis , K. (2007). Skills
Every Auto Mechanic Should Have. Wyo Tech.
Palincsar, A. S., & Brown, A. L. (1984). Reciprocal teaching of comprehension-fostering and
monitoring activities. Cognition and Instruction, 1: 117–175.
Paris, S. C.,
&Winograd, P. (1990). How metacognition can promote academic learning and instruction. In B. F. Jones & L. Idol (Eds.), Dimensions of thinking and
cognitive instruction. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Paris, S. G.
&Winograd, P. (1990). Promoting metacognition and motivation of exceptional
children. Remedial and Special Education, 11(6): 7-15.
Resnick, L. B. (1989). Learning in school and out, Educational Researcher, 5- 8.
Ribbens, W. B. (2003). understanding automotive electronics fifth edition. New
York: Elsevier Science .pp.470.
Richter, L.
&Panday, S., (2006). Youth conceptions of the transition to adulthood in South Africa:
Barriers and opportunities. Feature: Sexuality in Africa Magazine.
Roadside
Mechanics in Ghana.(Tarkwa Nsueam Municipality). International Journal of Scientific
Research and Innovative Technology, 2(6), 58-63.
Rogoff, B. & Lave, J. (Eds.)
(1988). Everyday cognition: its development in social context. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
Rogoff, B. (1984). Introduction:
Thinking and learning in social context. In B. Rogoff& J. Lave (Eds.),
Everyday cognition: Its development in social context (pp.1-8). Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University Press.
Rogoff, B. (1990). Apprenticeship
in thinking: Cognitive development in social context. New York: Oxford University
Press.
Rogoff, B. (1992). Three ways to
relate person and culture: Thoughts sparked by Valsiner's
review of Apprenticeship in Thinking. Human Development.35: 316- 320.
Salomon, G., Globerson, T., & Guterman, E.
(1989). The computer as a
zone of proximal development: Internalizing reading-related metacognitions from
a reading partner. Journal of Educational Psychology, 81(4),620
-627.
Salomon, G., Sr Perkins, D. N.
(1989). Rocky roads to transfer: Rethinking mechanisms of a neglected
phenomenon. Educational Psychologist, 24(2), 113-142.
Sambo,
M. N., Idris, S. H., & Shamang, A.
(2012).Determinants of occupational health hazards among roadside automobile
mechanics in Zaria, North Western Nigeria. Borno
Medical Journal, 9(1), 5-9.
Sandberg, J.
and Wielinga, B. (1992). Situated cognition: A paradigm shift? Journal of Artificial
Intelligence in Education, 3, 129-138.
Santini,
A. (2004). automotive electronic 2nd edition. Glen
Ellyn, Illinois: Cengage Learning.pp.544.
Scardamalia, et al. (1994). The CSILE project: Trying to bring the classroom into World 3. In K. Mcgilly (Ed). Classroom
Lessons: Integrating Cognitive Theory and Classroom Practice. Cambridge: MIT
Press.
Schank, R. C. (1994). Goal-Based Scenarios. In Roger
C. Schank and Ellen Langer (Eds.), Beliefs,
Reasoning, and Decision Making: Psycho-Logic in Honor
of Bob Abelson (pp. 1-32). Hillsdale, NJ.: Erlbaum.
Schank, R. C. and Edelson, D. J. (1989/90). A role for AI in education: Using
technology to reshape education. Journal of Artificial Intelligence in
Education, 1(2): 3-20.
Schank, R. C. and Jona, M. Y. (1991).Empowering the
student: New perspectives on the design of teaching systems. The Journal of the
Learning Sciences, 1(1): 7-35.
Schank, R. C., Berman, T., & McPherson, J. (1999). Learning by doing. In C. M. Reigeluth (Ed.), Instructional design theories and models:
A new paradigm of instructional theory (pp. 161–181). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence
Erlbaum.
Schneider, W.
& Lockl, K. (2002). The development of metacognitive knowledge in
children and adolescents. In Perfect, T. & Schwartz, B. (Eds.), Applied metacognition. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University
Press.
Schneider, W.
(2008). The development of
metacognitive knowledge in children and adolescents: Major trends and
implications for education. Mind, Brain, and Education, 2(3): 114-121.
Schoenfeld, A. H. & diSessa,
A. A. & Stage, E. (Eds.) (1974).Toward a scientific practice of science
education. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, Erasmus. Translated
by R. A. B. Mynors and D.F. S. Thomson.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Schoenfeld, A. H. (1983). Problem
Solving in the Mathematics Curriculum: A Report, Recommendations and an
Annotated Bibliography. The Mathematical Association of
America, MAA Notes, No. 1.
Schoenfeld, A.H. (1985). Mathematical problem solving. New York: Academic Press.
Schon, D. (1986). The reflective practitioner. Basic Books
USA.
Siegler, A. L. &Shipley,
B. (1995). Metacognition: The development of selective attention strategies for
learning from texts. In H. Singer & R. B. Ruddell (Eds.),
Theoretical models and processes of reading (3rd ed., pp. 501-526).
Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
Sizer, T. R.
(1992). Horace's compromise:
The dilemma of the American high school. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co.
Tchombe, T. M. S. (2011). Theories of learning. In Nsamenang, A. B. & Tchombe,
T.M. S. (Eds) Handbook of African Educational Theories and Practices. A Generative Teacher Education Curriculum. Human Development Resource Centre. Bamenda. Pp
157-193.
The government of Ghana, (2013). Local
Enterprises and skills Development Programme
(LESDEP).Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development. Ministry of
Trade and Industry Ghana,
Thomas, J. W. (2000). A review of research on project-based learning. A Rafael,
CA: The Autodesk Foundation.
Tripp, S. D. (1993). Theories, traditions and situated learning. Educational
Technology, 33(3): 71-77.
Trochim,
W. (2006).Descriptive statistics in research Methods Knowledge base (Analysis
Descriptive Statistics) Retrieved from http//www.socialresearchmethods.net/kb/statistics.
Vrasidas, C., Zembylas, M., & Chamberlain, R. (2004).
The design of online learning communities: Critical
issues. Educational Media International. 41(2):
135-142.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1962). Thought and Language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
Vygotsky, L. S. (1977). The development of higher psychological functions. Soviet
Psychology, 16: 60–73.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind and
society: The development of higher mental processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society. UK: Cambridge University Press.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1987). The
Collected Works of L. S. Vygotsky, Volume 1: Problems of general psychology. R. W. Rieber & A. S. Carton (Eds.).
NY: Plenum Press.
Wenger, E. (1991). Insurance
claim processing: producing processors. Paper presented at the meeting of the
American Anthropological Association, Chicago.
Wenger, E. (1992). Learning from
apprenticeship: A configural perspective. Paper presented at the meeting of the
American Anthropological Association, San Francisco.
Wenger, E. (1992). Living and
learning in communities of practice: the case of claim processing. Paper
presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San
Francisco.
Wenger, E. (1992). Work, knowledge, and innovation. Presentation
at the Collaboration 92 Conference, San Francisco.
World Bank, (1994). Senegal: Private
Sector Assessment. Industry and Energy Division, Western
Africa Department, Washington, DC.
World Bank, (1995). Apprenticeship
Contracts, Small Enterprises and Credit markets in Ghana: World Bank Economic
Review.
Young, M.
(1995). Post-compulsory
education and training for a learning society. Australian and
New Zealand Journal of Vocational Educational Research. Brisbane,
Australia.
Young, M. F. (1993). Instructional design for situated learning. Educational
Technology Research and Development
Young, M. F. (1995). Assessment of situated learning using computer environments. Journal of Science Education and Technology,
4 (1): 89-96.
Zinchenko, V. P. (1985). Vygotsky's ideas about units for the
analysis of mind. In J. V. Wertsch (Ed.),
Culture, communication, and cognition: Vygotskian perspectives (pp. 94-118). Cambridge University Press.
|
Cite this Article: Lukong, TE (2022). Perceived Cognitive Strategies and the Acquisition of
Motor Mechanic Competency among Trainees of Auto Training Institutes in the Buea, Cameroon. Greener Journal of Psychology and Counselling, 4(1): 1-17. |