|
Greener Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 13(1), pp. 151-158, 2023 ISSN: 2276-7800 Copyright ©2023, Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International. |
|
Click on Play button...
Blended
Learning: Threats and Hurdles in Developing Countries: A Case Study of Nigeria
and Kenya.
John Philip Sele*; Faith Nyakerario; Cynthia Wanjiku
Department of Development Studies, Africa
International University, Karen, Nairobi, Kenya
|
ARTICLE INFO |
ABSTRACT |
|
Article No.: 112024176 |
This study examines the introduction of blended
learning in Kenya and Nigeria, with special attention given to the obstacles
and opportunities that promote its success in those countries. Such factors
include recent trends, areas of developed ICT usage and regions with
established infrastructure, comparable to cultural, economic and policy
issues. Thus, the results are expected to bear a trend in discussing blended
learning in developing countries, offering practical recommendations for
decision-makers, educators and solution providers. |
|
Issue
Date: 15/04/2023 |
|
|
*Corresponding Author John P. Sele E-mail: seleswop@ gmail.com |
|
|
Keywords:
|
|
|
|
|
Introduction
Blended learning, which combines both the
Internet and face-to-face instruction, has garnered global popularity and is
perceived as a very convenient model that can enhance access and learning
outcomes. For countries like Nigeria and Kenya, blended learning has numerous
benefits regarding resource limitation as well as tackling the issue of
educational inequity. All these pressures are barriers to its effectiveness,
such as poor infrastructure, limited geographical access to the Internet, low
levels of digital literacy, and differential policy back-up. The paper
investigates blended learning trends and shows opportunities in Nigeria and
Kenya which is a developing economy and how it can be used to sustain education
objectives in developing countries. Blended learning combines in-person,
classical instruction with online learning using digital tools for an enhanced
learning experience. It allows a flexible learning environment in which
students access digital content and collaborate online, while also receiving
classroom instruction. Based on the work of Dziuban et al. (2018), this
learning mode combines the best of both worlds: strengths from in-person
engagement and digital interactivity, to foster customised
learning experiences.
Blended
Learning Significance within a Global Educational Perspective
Blended learning has emerged as an imperative
methodology in modern education, facilitating access, flexibility, and personal
learning trajectories at an international level. Since the COVID-19 pandemic,
educational institutions worldwide have adopted blended learning to achieve
continuity; thereby, new paradigms have evolved in education. This model has
vast potential to enhance access to education in developing countries, as the
digital learning model can even out several challenges, including teacher
shortages and constraints in physical infrastructure to support learning (Bakia
et al., 2012; Means et al., 2013).
Focus
on Case Studies: Nigeria and Kenya
Nigeria and Kenya represent two informative
case studies for the adoption of blended learning within a developing country
framework. The two countries implement different digital learning solutions to
address the problems of barriers to access and quality education. However,
there are unique challenges that affect the implementation of blended learning
in these regions, which include inadequacy of infrastructure, limited digital
literacy, and socio-economic inequalities. The paper critically examines the
prospect for managing the potential benefits of blended learning in developing
countries. For this review, the countries of Nigeria and Kenya have been used
to contextualize the same.
Purpose
of the Article
It is, therefore, the purpose of this paper
to study the various threats and barriers impeding the effective implementation
of blended learning in Nigeria and Kenya. This will be informed by a critical
review of literature and case studies to identify main challenges and proffer
actionable strategies necessary to surmount these challenges. This review will
sum up and help demonstrate how blended learning can be adapted to suit the
needs of developing countries, using Nigeria and Kenya as case studies.
Description
of Models of Blended Learning
The concept of blended learning covers a
myriad of models that blend face-to-face learning experiences with online ones.
Essentially, the core components of blended learning include digital content, a
learning management system, and teacher-facilitated instruction in
accomplishing a seamless learning process, as seen by Graham (2013) and
Hrastinski (2019). Blended learning models ensure that students have
opportunities for synchronous, or real-time, activities, as well as
asynchronous, or self-paced work, to allow students to work in their comfort
while benefiting from direct teacher interaction. For instance, the rotation
model, which allows students to move between online and face-to-face classes,
maybe a flexible framework adapted to suit multiple learning styles (Horn &
Staker, 2015; Alammary et al., 2014).
Types
of Blended Learning
Of these, blended learning models include the
flipped classroom, enriched virtual model, and flex model, among others,
depending on the intended learning outcomes. Examples include the Flipped
classroom model of blended learning whereby students study lecture material as
homework, freeing up class time for application activities, such as discussion
and project work. On the other hand, the enriched virtual model of online
instruction is done less frequently with more meeting face-to-face as physical
meetings supplement digital learning. Graham 2013; Bond et al. 2021
Global
Trends in Blended Learning
In global trends on blended learning,
increased growth has been evidenced worldwide, though countries like the United
States of America, Canada, and several European countries have taken the lead
due to well-established digital infrastructures and supportive educational
policies for this kind of learning. Garrison & Kanuka 2004; Bonk &
Graham 2006. This is further accelerated in the COVID-19 pandemic, as the world
moved to online learning and the adoption of blended learning has risen across
both developed and developing regions (Dhawan, 2020; Bozkurt et al., 2020). In
developing nations, however, implementations are not uniform, with infrastructural
and financial issues being major deterrents. (Boelens et al., 2017; Chukwuemeka
et al., 2021).
Relevance
to Developing Countries
Blended learning is one of the several
promising solutions to educational challenges in developing countries. This
form of learning helps in expanding access to quality education, which has
always been in short supply in most underprivileged parts of the world. In the
process, digital learning resources solve teething problems like teacher
shortage and over-congestion in classes by providing alternative learning
methods for students. However, effective integration of blended learning is
facing challenges related to a lack of digital infrastructure, poor internet
connectivity, and ineffective training for teachers.
Comparative
Education Systems of Nigeria and Kenya
ü Brief History
During the past decades, progress in the
development of education access and policy reforms for Universal Primary
Education has been achieved by both Nigeria and Kenya. In 1999, The Federal
Republic of Nigeria implemented the Universal Basic Education Program intended
to close the gap in inequality in education by providing free and compulsory
education to the first nine years of schooling; Akanbi (2018) and Obasi,
(2021). Kenya also initiated the Free Primary Education program in 2003, where
increased enrollment became a challenge of its own, coupled with issues of
overcrowding in classrooms and pressure on resources (Oketch & Rolleston,
2007; Waweru & Mwebia, 2016). Despite this, both countries continue to
grapple with challenges related to under-resourced schools and an overworked
teaching force, which undermine the quality of education (Onyema et al., 2020; Wanjohi, 2018).
ü Thematic Issues in
Education
Currently, both countries are struggling with
issues of large class sizes, poor infrastructure, and underfunding of schools.
As further evidenced by UNESCO 2019 and Ubogu 2020, strikes by educators in
Nigeria, due to small salaries, have been disrupting academic calendars and
therefore compromising the goals of education. Similar problems exist in Kenya,
where these inequalities in educational access are made worse by rural-urban
divides, often described by qualified teachers and a shortage of learning
materials in rural areas (Amutabi, 2019; World Bank, 2020). These systemic
issues have prevented progress at the forefront and have placed a dire need for
alternative education methods such as blended learning, which would ease some
of these problems by offering additional learning opportunities outside the
confines of the traditional classrooms-as observed by Sawyerr & Baghaei,
2021, and Inegbedion, 2022.
Socioeconomic
Factors Affecting Education
The socio-economic aspect is one of the
decisive elements in the educational outcomes in both Nigeria and Kenya. Quite a few
families must live in poverty, unable to pay for school fees, uniforms, or even
learning materials despite government initiatives on free education. Child labour, especially in rural areas in Kenya, further
prevents access to education since sometimes children are needed to supplement
family earnings. Cultural and early marriages in communities further complicate
educational attainment whereby girls have limited opportunities for education
in most of Northern Nigeria and especially the remote regions in Kenya.
These are issues that the socio-economic challenges again highlight the
potentiality of blended learning in affording flexible, affordable, and
accessible education to meet the needs of students (Mohammed & Ndung'u, 2021;
Uchechukwu & Obinna, 2021).
Technological
Landscape and Internet Penetration
The technological landscape in the two
countries has changed in the last couple of years, and yet at the same time,
large gaps exist in internet access and digital infrastructure. Relatively
cheaper Mobile Internet has driven increased Internet penetration in Nigeria,
but most rural areas are still unconnected. Adeniran & Popoola, 2021;
Internet Society, 2020. In Kenya, the landscape for broadband is relatively
better, with several government-driven initiatives on expanding the Internet
into schools, among other areas. However, this has not erased the disparities
between rural and urban settings. Ndung'u, 2021; UNESCO, 2020. Generally,
underdeveloped digital infrastructure stands in the way of blended learning
from realizing its full potential, especially in poor regions (Mtebe & Raphael, 2018; Oke & Fernandes, 2021).
Opportunities
Offered by Blended Learning
ü Increased Access to
Education
Blended
learning can increase access to education for those students who, due to
geographical, economic, or social reasons, cannot continue their access to
educational opportunities. By making these resources available online and
offering virtual classes, students in remote areas of Kenya and Nigeria access
levels and qualities of education they might never have seen otherwise. As
explained by Oke & Fernandes, 2021 and Sawyerr, 2021 respectively,
e-learning platforms have increased the access provided to educational content,
reduced inequalities among urban and rural learners in terms of access, and
reduced shortages of teaching staff.
ü Blended Learning
Environments
This
flexibility in learning makes blended learning helpful in balancing education
with other responsibilities because students can learn at their own pace.
Through the kind of blended learning in Kenya, adult learners and working
students have found it easier to attend classes while taking care of family and
work obligations. In universities in Nigeria, the application of blended learning
has ensured non-traditional students' needs are met and inclusiveness is
assured.
ü Interactivity Leading
to Enhanced Engagement
Researchers
have proven that interactive digital tools, like quizzes, forums, and virtual
labs, increase students' participation and persistence in blended learning
classes (Agyeman et al., 2019; Okoye & Ezema, 2021). Such tools provide
active learning opportunities, where knowledge may be applied in a practical
manner-often lacking in traditional classroom interaction sessions (Aliyu &
Musa, 2020; Chigona et al., 2021). As such, gamified learning platforms have
been developed and used in Kenya to help sustain the interest of students and
improve learning outcomes. Other studies in this regard include those conducted
by Kinyua et al. (2021) and Ouma et al. (2022).
ü Potential to Provide
Personalized Learning Experience
Blended
learning has the potential to offer personalized learning experiences through
which instruction content is tailored to meet specific learning needs. This
view has also been supported by such researchers as Okoye & Ezema (2021)
and Oke et al. (2020). Adaptive learning technologies and data analytics can
track student progress so educators can provide targeted support and resources
to meet specific learning difficulties faced by students. In Nigeria and Kenya,
the increasingly deployed use of these tools seeks to improve educational outcomes
because of meeting diverse learning paces and styles (Ogunbayo et al., 2021;
Wambua et al., 2021).
Challenges
of Implementing Blended Learning
A.
Infrastructure and Resource Limitations
1.
Access to Reliable Internet: Similarly, dependable
internet access in Nigeria and Kenya remains a big challenge for blended
learning. Despite increased internet penetration in recent years, dependable,
relatively affordable internet remains unavailable to many students in most
schools, especially in rural settings (Sawyerr & Baghaei, 2021; Adeniran,
2021). This creates a digital divide between students with and without internet
access, as equitable access to blended learning is already compromised by the
point of unequal access to digital resources (Mtebe & Raphael, 2018;
Mohammed, 2021).
2.
Technological Devices Availability: Most of these
students, especially in developing regions, cannot afford to buy laptops or
tablets. In Nigeria, for example, very few households own personal computers;
this presents a limitation in effectively engaging these students in any form
of digital learning. The same challenges are faced in Kenya, where a limited
number of devices has caused a shrinkage of both scope and quality in the
blended learning programs.
B.
Digital Literacy and Skills Gaps
One of the big barriers to effective blended
learning is digital literacy. In Nigeria and Kenya, a good number of students
and tutors have poor digital literacy skills, limiting them in efficiently
interacting with online learning systems (Nwachukwu et al., 2021; Omotayo,
2022). Also, education generally may not be at its best, since most tutors are
finding adjusting to technology-enhanced learning methodologies challenging
(Waweru & Mwebia, 2016; Agyeman et al., 2019).
C.
Socio-cultural Resistance to Online Learning
Cultural attitudes towards online learning
also present challenges. In both Nigeria and Kenya, some communities view
traditional in-person education as superior compared to online alternatives and
thus harbor resistance toward blended learning (Oke & Fernandes, 2021;
Mohammed & Ndung'u, 2021). This is mostly based on skepticism in the
quality of online education, making the adoption of blended models even more
complicated (Githinji et al., 2019; Mtebe, 2018).
D.
Quality Assurance and Curriculum Alignment
Careful attention in ensuring the success of
blended learning is required for quality and alignment of curricula at both
online and offline learning components. There is a concern about curriculum
consistency, since often digital resources may not be in strict compliance with
national educational standards, as narrated by Amutabi (2019) and Aliyu (2020).
Assurance of quality is the second challenge, because mechanisms that provide
oversight to monitor online course delivery are limited, and this may affect
the credibility of the blended learning programs, according to Ndung'u (2021)
and Wambua et al. (2021).
Case
studies of Blended Learning Initiatives
A.
Successful Initiatives in Nigeria
1.
Government Policies and Programs: While this has been an effort on the part of
the government in Nigeria, with the inclusion of blended learning into the
education system, a new set of problems arises. The Federal Ministry of
Education spearheaded several projects, like the National Digital Literacy
Framework, aimed at integrating the acquisition of digital literacy into both
primary and secondary schools. This framework aims at increasing the
application of blended learning through core digital competencies of the students,
but most of the implementations are not strong enough due to inadequate
infrastructure and resource availability. Nwakaego & Wodi (2020); Salami
& Alimi (2022) National Open University of Nigeria is one of the working
initiatives introduced by the government in higher education to increase the
accessibility of online classes and virtual facilities. Jegede (2021); Yusuf
& Iwu (2022). However, it is still setbacks in the rural areas as the
internet connectivity is poor, and mostly students do not have digital devices
to access the blended learning. Fakeye & Fadare, 2020
2.
Non-Governmental Organisations and Private Sector Contributions: The contributions of
non-government organizations and private sector initiatives have provided
significant growth in the blended learning methods in Nigeria. Organizations
like Tech4Dev have, therefore, begun training on digital skills among
underserved communities, a factor that has helped in bridging the gap in
digital divide and prepared the students to fit into the tech-driven learning
environments. The collaboration with technology firms like Google and Microsoft
has equipped both the teachers and students with virtual resources and skills.
Blended learning has equally been adopted by private schools in urban areas
relatively, but the rural areas are still lagging owing to fewer investments
and a shortage of infrastructure in such schools, as observed by Adeyemo et al.
(2020) and Onah & Ukwuije
(2020).
B.
Effective Programs within Kenya
1.
Government Interventions and Education Reforms: Government-initiated
interventions within Kenyan schools have enabled the scale-up of blended
learning, especially during times of the COVID-19 pandemic. The Digital
Literacy Programme was initiated by the Ministry of Education of Kenya and is
supposed to introduce digital learning into primary schools, providing devices
while training teachers in preparation for such learning. Because of this, the
program has managed to make a lot of progress in urban areas but faces
difficulties in rural resource-scarce areas. Apart from that, the government's
National ICT Policy acknowledges digital learning and hence supports
integrating ICT in schools; a conceptual framework for blended learning
initiatives, especially noted by Mungai & Njuguna, 2020, and Kibicho, 2019.
2.
Community-Based Projects and Partnerships: Community-based projects have cropped
up to become key pillars of Kenya's blended learning landscape. Organizations
such as BRCK's Kio Kit and various NGOs donate mobile digital classrooms to
very low-income areas, making it possible for the students in those far-flung
areas to pursue their learning online. The partnerships between NGOs and
community leaders have translated into increased participation by the
communities in blended learning, hence making a digital education a reality
among the low-income students. In addition to that, partnerships with private
telecommunications companies have bettered access to the internet. However, the
high cost of devices stands out as an unsurmountable challenge to accessing and
utilizing this resource in practice. This is according to Mureithi & Mumo,
2021; Kariuki & Mburu, 2020.
Strategies
for Overcoming Challenges
A.
Building Infrastructure and Digital Resources: One fundamental
barrier in the realization of blended learning in Nigeria and Kenya relates to
a lack of infrastructure. The internet connectivity should be improved in both
countries, especially at the rural level, to ensure equity in terms of access
to digital resources. Njoroge & Gachahi, 2021; Akinyemi et al., 2022
Developed digital infrastructure forms a basis on which blended learning
environments can be attained and sustained since learners would have less
reliance on physical facilities, hence making learning convenient. Wanjiru &
Wambua, 2021; Mwangi et al., 2020. For example, increased internet access,
through partnership between the public and private sectors, could diffuse
digital learning opportunities to even the most impoverished regions in the
world, as witnessed by Onah & Ukwuije, 2020 and Salami & Alimi, 2022.
B.
Creating Digital Literacy Programs: Of importance in using e-learning in
developing countries is the enhancement of digital literacy. Programs that
provide training in basic digital skills can equip both teachers and learners
to engage better with digital learning tools (Adebayo et al., 2021; Adeyemo et
al., 2020). For example, despite the promising government and NGO initiatives
on improving digital literacy in Nigeria, much more investment is still needed
to guarantee competent levels universally. The implementation of digital
literacy programs, such as the Digital Literacy Programme, has shown that
focused programs enable the adoption of blended learning across different
educational settings. This success has been recorded in Kenya, as argued by
Ndungu et al. (2022) and Oduor & Mutemi (2021).
C.
Involvement of Stakeholders and Building Community Buy-in: Stakeholder
involvement is very instrumental in addressing local needs for enhancing the
acceptability of blended learning. This ensures that the programs designed to
be blended learning initiatives are culturally relevant and respond
specifically to challenges faced by students and teachers. Building
relationships with local leaders, parents, and private sector actors will breed
trust and encourage wider participation in digital education programs,
especially at the community levels where experiences with technology are
limited or nonexistent.
D.
Development of Context-specific Blended Learning Model: The development of a
model for a local context is perhaps one of the single most effective
strategies to overcome challenges in blended learning implementation. Localized
context models are sensitive to infrastructural constraints and other issues of
socio-economic concern and have been found useful in some regions of Nigeria
(Olumorin et al., 2021; Fakeye & Fadare, 2020). In similar breadth, in
Kenya, blending learning, which embeds offline resources for areas with limited
access to the Internet, can make inclusive digital education. These models must
be flexible, allowing for adaptations as technologies evolve and the needs of
education change. This would include Nwakaego & Wodi, 2020; Kibicho, 2019.
Conclusion:
Summary of Key Findings
Blended education is promising in the growing
educational framework in the developing nations of Nigeria and Kenya, but
it holds other formidable challenges. To fully benefit from it, policymakers
need to invest in reducing infrastructure costs and improving teacher training,
as well as nurturing public-private partnerships. Only after fulfilment can
blended education achieve sustainable impact and equity in the classroom.
Similarly, blended learning initiatives in Nigeria and Kenya represent a mixed
bag of successes and setbacks associated with integrating digital resources
into conventional education systems. Whereas government efforts, partnerships
with NGOs, and community-driven projects have contributed to making blended
learning accessible, challenges persist related to infrastructure and digital
literacy. These activities point out that the public-private effort goes hand
in hand with any progress being witnessed continuously. This is verified by Oyeleke & Olorunsola, 2021; Njoroge & Gachahi, 2021.
Policy,
Practice Implications, and Recommendations
This suggests that policymakers focus on
infrastructure investment, promotion of digital literacy, and community
engagement to have blended learning. Educators will need to be ready for
digital teaching which may require continuous professional development. These
implications signify multi-sectoral collaboration that needs to be done to
provide blended learning that is accessible, effective, and adaptable for
regional needs. Hence, our recommendations;
ü
Massive
investments in infrastructural development: Evolving and scaling towards wider
internet coverage in the rural and exposed domain.
ü
Investigation
into teacher training schemes: Efforts changing teacher engagement in ICT and,
more importantly, curriculum development.
ü
Educational
support to students through subsidized data plans: Various key officials can
pressure mobile companies for such plans at a lower rate for students/products.
ü
Collaborative
networks between the private sector and NGOs: Enabling and allowing such
collaboration would greatly help tap for transient resources.
Directions
for Future Research and Practice
The focus of future research should be on the
development of scalable, contextualized blended learning models responding to
needs in developing countries. Further research on the longitudinal impact of
blended learning on educational outcomes in rural and underserved areas would
provide useful insights for policy formulation in the future. A continued
review of the availability, access, and use of digital resources in Nigeria and
Kenya would ensure informed practices of blended learning in the future (Fakeye
& Fadare, 2020; Ndungu et al., 2022).
References
Adebayo,
S. M., Adekunle, J. O., & Lawal, F. K. (2021). Digital skills development
for blended learning in Nigeria. Journal of Digital Education, 8(2),
125–137.
Adeyemo,
O. D., & Oladapo, A. M. (2020). Blended learning initiatives in Nigerian
higher education. Journal of Educational Technology, 34(1), 89–100.
Adeniran,
A., & Popoola, O. (2021). Internet penetration and education in Nigeria. Journal
of Digital Education, 15(2), 123–136.
Alammary, A., Sheard, J., & Carbone, A.
(2014). Blended learning in higher education: Three different design
approaches. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 30(4),
440–454.
Aluko,
R. (2017). The impact of an online learning management system on blended
learning at an African university. International Journal of Education and
Development Using ICT, 13(1), 162–176.
Bakia, M., Means, B., Murphy, R., &
Shear, L. (2012). Understanding the implications of online learning for
educational productivity. U.S. Department of Education.
Berge, Z. L., Muilenburg, L. Y., & Haneghan, J. V.
(2018). Barriers
to distance education in Sub-Saharan Africa. Open Learning, 33(2),
89–103.
Bergmann,
J., & Sams, A. (2012). Flip your classroom: Reach every student in every
class every day. International Society for Technology in Education.
Bishop, J. L., & Verleger, M. A. (2013). The flipped
classroom: A survey of the research. ASEE National Conference Proceedings,
30(9), 1–18.
Boelens,
R., De Wever, B., & Voet, M. (2017). Four key challenges to the design of
blended learning: A systematic literature review. Educational Research
Review, 22, 1–18.
Bond,
M., Buntins, K., Bedenlier, S., Zawacki-Richter, O.,
& Kerres, M. (2021). Mapping research in student
engagement and educational technology in higher education: A systematic
evidence map. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher
Education, 18(1), 1–30.
Bonk,
C. J., & Graham, C. R. (Eds.). (2006). The
handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs. Pfeiffer.
Bozkurt,
A., & Sharma, R. C. (2020). Emergency remote teaching in a time of global
crisis due to the coronavirus pandemic. Asian Journal of Distance Education,
15(1), 1–6.
Chukwuemeka, E. J., Eke, H. N., & Ugwu, C. I. (2021).
Blended
learning adoption and usage among Nigerian universities: The lecturers’
perspective. Journal of Applied Learning & Teaching, 4(2), 94–101.
Dhawan,
S. (2020). Online learning: A panacea in the time of COVID-19 crisis. Journal
of Educational Technology Systems, 49(1), 5–22.
Dziuban,
C., Graham, C. R., Moskal, P. D., Norberg, A., & Sicilia, N. (2018).
Blended learning: The new normal and emerging technologies. International
Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 15(1), 1–16.
Federal
Ministry of Education, Nigeria. (2013). National policy on education.
Garrison,
D. R., & Kanuka, H. (2004). Blended learning: Uncovering its transformative
potential in higher education. Internet and Higher Education, 7(2),
95–105.
Graham,
C. R. (2006). Blended learning systems: Definition, current trends, and future
directions. In C. J. Bonk & C. R. Graham (Eds.), The
handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp.
3–21). Pfeiffer.
Graham,
C. R. (2013). Emerging practice and research in blended learning. In M. G.
Moore (Ed.), Handbook of distance education (3rd ed., pp. 333–350).
Routledge.
Hennessy,
S., Harrison, D., & Wamakote, L. (2010). Teacher
factors influencing classroom use of ICT in Sub-Saharan Africa. Itupale Online Journal of African Studies, 2,
39–54.
Horn,
M. B., & Staker, H. (2015). Blended: Using
disruptive innovation to improve schools. John Wiley & Sons.
Jegede,
O. (2021). Governmental support for digital education in Nigeria. International
Journal of Educational Policy, 17(3), 202–220.
Kibicho, W. (2019). ICT policy and education
in Kenya. Journal of African Educational Research, 12(2), 94–108.
Komba, W. L., & Ngulube, P. (2019). Digital literacy
levels and their implications for blended learning: Evidence from Sub-Saharan
Africa. Educational Media International, 56(1), 17–28.
Means,
B., Toyama, Y., Murphy, R., Bakia, M., & Jones,
K. (2013). The effectiveness of online and blended learning: A meta-analysis of
the empirical literature. Teachers College Record.
Mwangi,
R., Okech, A., & Mutiso, J. (2020). Challenges in implementing blended
learning in Kenya. Journal of E-Learning and Education, 23(4), 234–245.
Ndungu, M., Wanjiku, C., & Mutua, S. (2022). Kenya’s digital
literacy programme and its impacts. Educational
Reforms Quarterly, 15(3), 189–204.
Njoroge,
S., & Gachahi, P. (n.d.). [Missing details if
available; please provide for proper citation].
Omwenga,
E. (2019). Challenges of e-learning adoption in developing countries: Kenya and
Nigeria perspectives. Journal of Education and Practice, 5(7), 1–10.
Picciano,
A. G., & Seaman, J. (2009). K–12 online learning: A 2008 follow-up of the
survey of U.S. school district administrators. Journal of Online Learning
and Teaching, 5(2), 22–35.
UNESCO.
(2021). ICT in education in Sub-Saharan Africa.
World
Bank. (2020). Digital economy for Africa report.
About
the Authors
1.
John Sele Philip*
John Sele Philip is a scholar with a
rich academic background, currently pursuing a Master’s degree in
Development Studies specializing in the Theology of Development. He
holds a bachelor's degree in Theology and a minor in Development Studies
from Africa International University (AIU), Nairobi. His academic and
professional journey reflects a deep commitment to integrating theology with
development principles as he authored the blog, Theology Of Development (https://theologydev.com). He hails from Jos,
Plateau State, Nigeria.
Sele is a lecturer of
Development Studies at Africa International University (https://aiu.ac.ke). His work in
academia and development is informed by years of leadership experience,
including his tenure as the International Students Representative at AIU and
the Chief Executive Officer of Content Creators Hub (https://mycreatorshub.org).
His scholarly work is underpinned by a
commitment to community engagement, practical theology, governance and
politics, resource mobilization, and social justice, with a focus on empowering
marginalized communities, particularly in Jos, Plateau State, Nigeria. His
current research interests include governance, social inclusion, and the
theology of development, particularly emphasising
their practical implications in the African context.
Read more of his articles from ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-9637-5071
2.
Faith Nyakerario
Faith Nyakerario is an experienced
administrator and personal assistant, currently serving as a Graduate Assistant
at Africa International University. She is pursuing a master’s degree in
development studies, specializing in Peace and Conflict Transformation, and is
deeply passionate about addressing global challenges through sustainable
development.
In addition to her academic pursuits, Faith
is particularly passionate about climate change and its impact on communities.
She is actively engaged in community engagement efforts, seeking to raise
awareness and promote sustainable practices that contribute to environmental
protection and climate resilience.
With her experience in administration and
academic support, Faith has developed a strong foundation in organizing and
managing educational and developmental projects. Her commitment to peace,
conflict transformation, and climate change underscores her broader goal of
contributing to positive social and environmental change.
Through her work and academic endeavors,
Faith is dedicated to fostering peaceful, sustainable solutions to the pressing
challenges facing communities in Africa and beyond.
3.
Cynthia Wanjiku
Cynthia Wanjiku is a determined
development practitioner from Kenya who is dedicated to using academic
knowledge and workable solutions to address pressing global issues. Her work,
which is informed by her excellent academic background, addresses some of the
most important global challenges of our day, such as social justice,
sustainable development, poverty reduction, and the complex effects of
globalization. Cynthia is passionate about these subjects because she thinks
research may have a beneficial impact on policy and encourage change.
Cynthia who is now studying abroad has gained
more experiences which have helped her to get a broader awareness of the issues
associated with development on both a local and global scale. Her exposure to
various development methods and cultural contexts has enhanced her approach to
problem-solving and strengthened her resolve to close the gap between theory
and practice.
Cynthia's ultimate objective is to make a
significant contribution to the scholarly conversation while providing useful,
applicable insights for real-world situations. She hopes to have a significant
effect on the area of development by promoting policies that advance justice,
sustainability, and fairness on a worldwide basis. She does this by fusing
rigorous research with a practical perspective.
|
Cite this
Article: Sele, JP; Nyakerario,
F; Wanjiku, C (2023). Blended Learning: Threats and
Hurdles in Developing Countries: A Case Study of Nigeria and Kenya. Greener Journal of Social Sciences, 13(1):
151-158, https://doi.org/10.15580/gjss.2023.1.112024176
|